Came back to this thread to see if anyone found anything. Guess not. I did do a little more searching though, and came up with the 6 live threads from the debate in question, which was the first Bush/Gore debate from 10/3/2000.
This thread has links to all 6 threads. Lots of humorous comments about the makeup throughout, but I don't think it's what you're looking for.
http://www.freerepublic.com/forum/a39dabfc40972.htm
No ... ty vm MCH ... believe me, you would know the thread if you saw it. Someone has it on his/her personal page, or did have it about a year ago. I came across it accidentally.
It has a pic of Algore which was astounding.