Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Michael81Dus
First off I do not understand your comments relating to Iraq and Saddam.

"Do you think that someone who has the same passport with a criminal loses his basic rights? Do you think that it would have been ok to bomb Bagdads houses and flats in 1991 because Saddam attacked Kuwait?"

I am very proud of the American troops which captured Saddam Hussein. What actions did Germany take in forcing Saddam to abide by countless UN resolutions?

"But tell me why you refuse to acknowledge that Germans were victims, too?" I never stated Germans which opposed the Nazis were not victims of Hitlers madness. When Germany was beating the living Hell out of every nation the 3rd Reich's storm troopers invaded, there were frenzied celebrations all over Germany. Their leader was producing a greater German Reich for them, correct?

"2 million were murdered or died on the run after being expelled from the former East German areas."

While I never defend the despicable, barbaric actions of Stalins communist horde, you need to ask yourself who invaded whom, even after both beastly tyrants, Hitler & Stalin signed their 'Nazi-Soviet Pact' in 1939 after they carved up Poland and other eastern nations and then what happened in 1941?

The toast to evil -Nazi Germany & Red Russia

One bastard stabbed the other in the back. Hitler and his Nazi goons already thrilled with blitzing the lowlands, France & Norway, plus bombing England decide to invade Stalin's Soviet Union.

Would Stalin have attacked Germany, most likely given a few more years of arming to the teeth, but the Berlin beat Moscow to the punch.

Both nations had monsters in control. Germany elected there monster, while Stalin bullied his way to communist power murdered anyone in his path, same as Hitler.

"No, by far not all Germans who died or lost all in WW2 "deserved" their fate."

Every cold blooded Nazi, if there were ever brought to justice, deserved everything which was coming to them, and more, after butchering millions of people.

..."several hundreds were shot by the western allied without sentence - many many Privates among them."

Remember Malmedy? I do.

The inhuman legacy of Nazi Germany -


27 posted on 05/11/2005 5:43:58 PM PDT by M. Espinola (Freedom is never free.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 23 | View Replies ]


To: M. Espinola

You make the fault that you set German equals Nazi. This is plain wrong. The very most people weren´t Nazis, they kept silent, even because they were oppressed by the regime. It´s not like that the NSDAP asked the voters and the President (who appointed Hitler to Chancellor): "Do you want a global war, do you want us to kill all Jews, do you want to lose your rights to opposition, free speech, regualar fair elections?"

Of course, everybody who actively and voluntary followed the Nazi course against minorities (not only Jews, though they were the highest number) deserves what he has got.

But tell me why the German Private at the front in Russia deserved to die of hunger or a disease as a POW in a Sibirian camp in 1955 (!), or why the German women deserved to be expelled from her home in East Prussia? Tell me why the Hitler Youth member with 14 years deserved to be killed by a British grenade in the last days of war? They didn´t deserve their fate.

Learn that we practise the principle of individual guilt.
Compare Iraq of 1991 with Germany of 1939. When you think that the German people as a whole deserved to be destroyed, do you think that the Iraqis should have been bombed out in 1991? Do you think that intentional destroying of houses and flats (=killing civilians) is a proper way of leading a war?
I hope your answer is no. Then please use this measure for your view on the WW2-history.


36 posted on 05/11/2005 11:46:09 PM PDT by Michael81Dus
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 27 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson