Posted on 05/13/2005 2:03:47 AM PDT by LukeSW
Am sick of all the second guessers.
I suppose we can say that since hundreds of thousands of planes have flown over NY, PA, and D.C. without incident, then there will be NO incident in the future.
Kind of like the Michael Jackson defense. Look at all the boys he didn't molest, therefore......
Olde...Your usual thinking cap is missing today.
Actually one at the state of development of both nations would be too heavy for this aircraft.
This is a Cessna 150
A suitcase nuke or suitcase bomb is a very compact and portable nuclear weapon and could have the dimensions of 60 x 40 x 20 centimeters or 24 x 16 x 8 inches. The smallest possible bomb-like object would be a single critical mass of plutonium (or U-233) at maximum density under normal conditions.
The Pu-239 weighs 10.5 kg and is 10.1 cm across. It doesn't take much more than a single critical mass to cause significant explosions ranging from 10-20 tons. These types of weapons can also be as big as two footlockers.
The physics of the Cessna 150 make it an improbable terror weapon. Indeed, we have an incident to show us that a Cessna 150 is not much threat to the White House.
A Cessna 150 does not a warplane make.
A Cessna 150 waould make a dangerous warplane indeed .
Government Alert: Hospital Security Breach
This really has federal authorities puzzled - intruders masquerading as doctors and inspectors probing hospital security. But there is no evidence the cases are connected, including two in New Jersey. Hospital officials and security experts say the similarities are disturbing.
It happened on Easter Sunday. Three men of middle-eastern descent entered a Sussex County hospital posing as physicians.
Watch For Impostors, Homeland Security Warns City Hospitals
New York City hospitals are on the lookout for impostors trying to scope out health-care facilities and locate radioactive materials following warnings late last month from the Department of Homeland Security and the city Police Department about an emerging pattern of suspicious incidents in some American cities.
Stowaway on American nuke-powered aircraft carrier
A Newport man who boarded an American nuclear-powered aircraft carrier anchored in The Solent has been made subject to an anti-social behaviour order and banned from named sensitive areas.
Abdoul Masmoud Yessoufou, 37, whose address was given at Portsmouth Magistrates Court on Wednesday as East Street, Newport, admitted entering a prohibited area at Portsmouth Docks.
The court was told that Yessoufou was found on the USS Harry S. Truman at the weekend after he strolled past guards and hitched a ride out to the carrier on a boat used by sailors on runs ashore.
Yessoufou had previously appeared before Uxbridge Magistrates three times this year for entering restricted zones at Heathrow. He also reached the side of an aircraft at Southampton Airport in January.
As has been repeatedly pointed out by many posters your odds of getting a nuke closer to the center of DC are infinitely better with a car or truck than an aircraft.
Simply shooting the plane down would prevent the appearance of panic, if image is so darned important.
Tiny Nukes-- the backpack threat
The smallest US nukes ever made had yields on the order of 0.02 kilotons:
The trucks did not spread the material, or if they did, the local airflow around the trucks was insufficient to provide a satisfactory aerosol effect.
A light plane could readily cover a vast area with Anthrax spores due to it's speed and altitude.
I don't understand why you are so impatient to "disprove" the idea that Anthrax can be spread in an aerosol form.
I'm sick of this. Washington DC DID NOT go in a panic mode. I was in DC and outside of the capitol building nobody went anywhere. In fact, I was outside for lunch at the time and the streets were no busier than usual and I'm only 4 blocks from the White House. Don't believe everything you hear on TV.
Excellent post!
I can't believe that some people here either don't understand that we are at war or think that this country doesn't have enemies that would try something like this. How could anyone in their right mind see all the stuff going on in the world today such as suicide bombers walking into crowded public places, daily car bombs in Iraq, guys trying to blow up commercial jets with a shoe, anthrax being sent through the mail, etc., and think that an unresponsive plane flying in a NO FLY ZONE towards the White House and Capitol is no biggie? Unbelievable.
God knows, a guy that flys is taking his (and other) life into his own hands. He sure as hell better believe in himself. The risk comes when the hubris makes the pilot bold, thus increasing his chances of not becoming old.
I suspect cooler heads did IN FACT weigh the probability and negate any shooting down. I give them credit for this as it is their job and they made the right decision.
Black and white shootdown policy should never be adopted. Sane, cool, trained minds, must evaluate first, not react without thought.
How much anthrax would be needed to create a problem? Isn't it a gaggle of geese and a herd of goats?
RESOURCE CENTERNational Terror Alert (NTARC)
http://www.nationalterroralert.com/readyguide/suitcasenuke.htm
A suitcase nuke or suitcase bomb is a very compact and portable nuclear weapon and could have the dimensions of 60 x 40 x 20 centimeters or 24 x 16 x 8 inches. The smallest possible bomb-like object would be a single critical mass of plutonium (or U-233) at maximum density under normal conditions.
The Pu-239 weighs 10.5 kg and is 10.1 cm across. It doesn't take much more than a single critical mass to cause significant explosions ranging from 10-20 tons. These types of weapons can also be as big as two footlockers.
The warhead of a suitcase nuke or suitcase bomb consists of a tube with two pieces of uranium, which, when rammed together, would cause a blast. Some sort of firing unit and a device that would need to be decoded to cause detonation may be included in the "suitcase."
Another portable weapon is a "backpack" bomb. The Soviet nuclear backpack system was made in the 1960s for use against NATO targets in time of war and consists of three "coffee can-sized" aluminum canisters in a bag. All three must be connected to make a single unit in order to explode. The detonator is about 6 inches long. It has a 3-to-5 kiloton yield, depending on the efficiency of the explosion. It's kept powered during storage by a battery line connected to the canisters.
And I loved this one: "You just can't do a lot of damage with 2,000 lbs unless it's all explosives.
DUH!!! Give this wing-nut a cigar, please.
What do you think, that someone bent of wreaking havoc and decimation would have loaded in a plane Mr. Know-it-all, daisies or marshmallows?
Give me a break!
Im not a pilot (though I worked on planesbig mothersfor 3 years while in the AF) and likewise, I am not an expert on explosives, though I did see the results of a single 500 lb bomb while in Namnot very pretty.
Wonder what our genius Luke (who BTW, seems to have disappeared) would have to opine about the [probable] results of a Cessna loaded with 1500 lbs of Semtex traveling at the rate of speed of (oh, say maybe 150 knots in a sharp dive) and impacting a building? Might make for a pretty big bang?
I heard (in one report) that the pilots were not on instruments, but were flying by sight. I have a question for those of you who are pilots, especially small plane pilots. How many cities between Eastern PA and NC look like Washington, DC from the air?
I have flown over DC and looked down (in a commercial jet) and Washington's distinct circular design was very apparent. Of course, my view was from a higher altitude than most small planes fly, I would imagine. I just find it hard to believe one could not recognize DC in the distance, especially on a clear day.
What is there to think about? We know that terrorist organizations are targeting this country. We know that they are quite adept at coming up new and innovative ways to strike. We know that there is a very real threat of a small amount of a substance like anthrax or ricin being sprayed over densely populated areas from small planes. We know that that the area of the White House and Capitol is a particularly big target. We know that there is a NO FLY ZONE that begins 15 miles outside of this area. We know that the plane was not responding to calls to divert it's course and got to within 3 miles of the White House.
Frankly, I find it absolutely amazing that we know all of this stuff and the idiots in the plane were able to get out of the situation with their lives. Good for them, but had they been shot down I would not have been surprised nor would I have had a problem with it.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.