I thought it was cool. Took my 10-yr-old to see it twice. I haven't seen a movie more than once in the theater since 1977 (yup, Episode IV, seven times).
It is campy fun. Yes the acting mostly reeked. However, I was not disappointed in the injuries inflicted on Anakin. I was expecting something less, for some reason. Dang, lost both legs and an arm, then cathes on fire. Seemed pretty nasty to me (as it should have been). Also, just loved the scene when the helmet got snapped on... the deep, drawn breath... The wife, kid & I high-fived, chuckled, and said, "Yes!". It was perfect. Then the icing on the cake: hearing James Earl Jones voice. This one is right up there with IV & V, IMO. Regards, HW
Heheheh. The only thing lacking after he got that helmet on was, "Now, anyone have a Marlboro?"