"Applauded? As I recall, he didn't believe in Affirmative Action and was hoping for SCOTUS to do the right thing. When did he "applaud" it? Or, was it just his normal way of not badmouthing something he didn't like because he has too much class?"
Your recollection is incorrect. Here is Bush's statement on Grutter:
"I applaud the Supreme Court for recognizing the value of diversity on our Nation's campuses. Diversity is one of America's greatest strengths. Today's decisions seek a careful balance between the goal of campus diversity and the fundamental principle of equal treatment under the law.
My Administration will continue to promote policies that expand educational opportunities for Americans from all racial, ethnic, and economic backgrounds. There are innovative and proven ways for colleges and universities to reflect our diversity without using racial quotas. The Court has made clear that colleges and universities must engage in a serious, good faith consideration of workable race-neutral alternatives. I agree that we must look first to these race-neutral approaches to make campuses more welcoming for all students.
Race is a reality in American life. Yet like the Court, I look forward to the day when America will truly be a color-blind society. My Administration will continue to work toward this important goal."
Sounds strikingly like O'Connor in his language.
When he ran for President the first time, he was asked about things like affirmative action and gay rights. His position then, and now (funny how he stays consistent, but people hear what they want to hear in order to stay pissed) is that he believes in equal rights, not special rights. Why do y'all tend to find one statement that can be misconstrued and ignore the real meat?