Skip to comments.Hold Your Tears ... Mark Steyn
Posted on 08/18/2005 7:52:21 AM PDT by Rummyfan
Hold your tears Mark Steyn
Is it only five years since the White House press corps was spending its summers traipsing round Marthas Vineyard and the Hamptons watching Bill Clinton hang with Carly Simon and Steven Spielberg? Since the Bush terror, alas, theyve been condemned under a little-known provision of the Patriot Act to confinement in Crawford, Texas for one whole month a year. Crawford is where George W. Bush has his ranch and, other than that distinction, it is (as I wrote here in August 2000) a dusty crossroads in the middle of a drought-stricken, sun-broiled plain, population 690 with five churches but not a single hotel. Since the annual influx of journalists, they may have added a hotel but also no doubt half a dozen more churches just to wind up the godless hordes of the Fourth Estate.
Sadly, the media dont seem to enjoy the annual joke. So, with no showbiz types to hand in the Greater Waco area, someone had the bright idea of importing a little entertainment. These days, come August and the cry goes up, Hey, lets do the show in George W. Bushs barn. When it comes to political theatre, Crawford now finds itself playing host to the nations most critically acclaimed summer stock.
Last year it was former Georgia Senator Max Cleland, who took up residence outside the Bush ranch and demanded the President come out and denounce the Swift Boat veterans. Cleland, also a Vietnam vet and a triple amputee, was outraged that anyone would impugn Senator Kerrys war record and was impugning Bush for not impugning the Swift vets for impugning Kerry. Anyway, the President never did come out to meet Cleland. He may still be there for all I know.
This years performer in residence is Cindy Sheehan, whose son Casey was killed in Iraq last year. Mrs Sheehan is now very anti-war and has pledged to stay camped out in Crawford all August until the President has the guts to come out and see her for a face-to-face meeting. So far hes sent his national security adviser and deputy chief of staff out to see her, but thats like Clinton sending Janet Reno and Sidney Blumenthal to Carly Simons party. These no-name stand-ins were trying to bullshit us into submission, complained Mrs Sheehan.
Her sons loss like Max Clelands wounds is supposed to put her beyond reproach. For as the New York Timess Maureen Dowd informed us, The moral authority of parents who bury children killed in Iraq is absolute.
Really? Well, what about those other parents whove buried children killed in Iraq? Linda Ryan lost her son, Marine Corporal Marc Ryan, to insurgents in Ramadi: George Bush didnt kill her son, says Mrs Ryan. Her son made a decision to join the Armed Forces and defend our country.... George Bush was my sons commander-in-chief. My son, Marc, totally believed in what he was doing.
There are, sadly, hundreds of Linda Ryans across American: parents who buried children killed in Iraq and who honour their service to the nation. They dont make the news. Theres one Cindy Sheehan and shes on TV round the clock. She may not be emblematic of bereaved military families, but shes certainly symbolic of media-Left desperation.
Still, shes a mother. And, if youre as heavily invested as Ms Dowd in the notion that those killed in Iraq are children, then Mrs Sheehans status as grieving matriarch is a bonanza. I agree with Mrs Ryan: theyre not children in Iraq; theyre thinking adults who made a decision to join the Armed Forces and defend our country. Whenever Im on a radio show these days, someone calls in and demands to know whether my children are in Iraq. Well, not right now. They range in age from five to nine, and though thats plenty old enough to sign up for the jihad and toddle into an Israeli pizza parlour wearing a suicide-bomb, in most advanced societies armed forces they prefer to use grown-ups.
That seems to be difficult for the Left to grasp. Ever since Americas all-adult, all-volunteer army went into Iraq, the anti-war crowd have made a sustained effort to characterise them as children. If a 13-year-old wants to have an abortion, thats her decision and her parents shouldnt get a look-in. If a 21-year-old wants to drop to the Oval Office shagpile and chow down on Bill Clinton, shes a grown woman and free to do what she wants. But, if a 22- or 25- or 37-year old is serving his country overseas, hes a wee child who isnt really old enough to know what hes doing.
I get many emails from soldiers in Iraq, and they sound a lot more grown-up than most Ivy League professors and certainly than Maureen Dowd, who writes as if shes auditioning for a minor supporting role in Sex and the City. The infantilisation of the military promoted by the Left is deeply insulting to Americas warriors but it suits the anti-war crowds purposes. It enables them to drone ceaselessly that of course they support our troops, because they want to stop these poor confused moppets from being exploited by the Bush war machine.
So, when Cindy Sheehan came into view, Bush-disparagers from Washington to Hollywood cried Bingo! Cindy Sheehan is my hero, says Christine Lahti, former star of TVs Chicago Hope. You can run, Bush, but you cant hide. Her courage is waking up America. Evidently it woke up motion-picture personality Viggo Mortensen, who flew to Crawford on a pilgrimage to Mrs Sheehan. For the press corps, its not exactly the Spielberg/Clinton summer summit in the Hamptons, but its as close as theyre going to get.
I resisted writing about Mother Sheehan (as one leftie has proposed designating her), as it seemed obvious that she was at best a little unhinged by grief and at worst mentally ill. Start with her insistence on a face-to-face meeting with Bush. Even if you dont think the President should see her, you can sympathise with the demand, born out of her anger and pain. But it turns out shes already had a face-to-face meeting with Bush. Her son Casey was killed in April last year and in June the President met the Sheehans to offer his condolences. The story appeared in the 24 June 2004 edition of the Reporter, their hometown paper in Vacaville, California:
I now know hes sincere about wanting freedom for the Iraqis, Cindy said after their meeting. I know hes sorry and feels some pain for our loss. And I know hes a man of faith....
For the first time in 11 weeks, they felt whole again. That was the gift the President gave us, the gift of happiness, of being together, Cindy said.
Mrs Sheehan wants a second meeting with Bush because she no longer feels the way she did at the first one. Instead of gratitude for the gift the President gave us, she now says her son was murdered by the Bush crime family.
Also: We have to impeach George Bush down to the person who picks up the dog shit in Washington! Let George Bush send his two little party animals to die in Iraq.
Also: You tell me the truth. You tell me that my son died for oil. You tell me that my son died to make your friends rich. You tell me my son died to spread the cancer of Pax Americana.... You get America out of Iraq, you get Israel out of Palestine.
Well, OK, cut the lady some slack: a lot of folks get a bit overheated about Bush, and neocons, and Jews and so forth. But how about this? America has been killing people on this continent since it was started. This country is not worth dying for. That was part of her warm-up act for a speech by Lynne Stewart, the activist lawyer convicted of conspiracy for aiding the terrorists convicted of the 1993 World Trade Center bombing.
You can see why Lynnes grateful to Mrs Sheehan. But why is Elizabeth Edwards, wife of Kerrys running mate, sending out imploring letters headlined Support Cindy Sheehans Right To Be Heard? The politics of this isnt difficult: the more Cindy Sheehan is heard, the more obvious it is shes a kook to whom most Americans would give a wide berth.
Dont take my word for it, ask her family. Casey Sheehans grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins put out the following statement:
The Sheehan family lost our beloved Casey in the Iraq war and we have been silently, respectfully grieving. We do not agree with the political motivations and publicity tactics of Cindy Sheehan. She now appears to be promoting her own personal agenda and notoriety at the expense of her sons good name and reputation. The rest of the Sheehan family supports the troops, our country, and our President, silently, with prayer and respect.
Ah, well, theyre not immediate family, so they lack Cindys moral authority. But how about Caseys father, Pat Sheehan? Last Friday, in Solano County Court, Pat Sheehan filed for divorce. As the New York Times explained Cindys separation: Although she and her estranged husband are both Democrats, she said she is more liberal than he is, and now, more radicalised.
Toppling Saddam and the Taleban (Mrs Sheehan opposes US intervention in Afghanistan, too), destroying al-Qaedas training camps and helping 50 million Muslims on the first steps to free societies arent worth the death of a single soldier. But Cindy Sheehans hatred of Bush is worth the death of her marriage. Watching her and her advanced case of Bush Derangement Syndrome on TV, I feel the way I felt about that mentally impaired Aussie concert pianist they got to play at the Oscars a few years ago.
It was suggested by the columnist Cal Thomas that Bush should agree to a (second) meeting in public. Cindy Sheehan could let rip, but there would also be other bereaved moms of soldiers who dont feel as she does, and maybe some bereaved Iraqi moms to tell of their gratitude for the liberation of their country from a psycho regime. Its a fine idea, and Im sure the reason Bush wont do it is because he understands that Mrs Sheehan is having a mental breakdown in public and it would be cruel to take advantage of that. If only the Michael Moore Left had that much decency.
But in the wreckage of Pat and Cindy Sheehans marriage there is surely a lesson for the Democratic party. As Cindy says, theyre both Democrats, but shes more liberal and more radicalised. There are a lot of less liberal and less radicalised Dems out there: theyre soft-left-ish on healthcare and the environment and education and so forth; many have doubts about the war, but they love their country, they have family in the military, and they dont believe in dishonouring American soldiers to make a political point. The problem for the Democratic party is that the Cindys are now the loudest voice: Michael Moore, Howard Dean, moveon.org, and Air America, the flailing liberal radio network distracting attention from its own financial scandals by flying down its afternoon host Randi Rhodes to do her show live from Camp Casey. The last time I heard Miss Rhodes she was urging soldiers called up for Iraq to refuse to go i.e., to desert and entertaining theories that 9/11 was Bushs Reichstag fire.
On unwatched Sunday talk shows you can still stumble across the occasional sane responsible Dem. But, in the absence of any serious intellectual attempt to confront their long-term decline, all the energy on the Left is with the fringe. The Democratic party is a coalition of Pat Sheehans and Cindy Sheehans, and the noisier the Cindys get the more estranged the Pats are likely to feel. Sorry about that, but, if Mrs Sheehan can insist her sons corpse be the determining factor in American policy on Iraq, I dont see why her marriage cant be a metaphor for the state of the Democratic party.
Casey Sheehan was a 21-year-old man when he enlisted in 2000. He re-enlisted for a second tour, and he died after volunteering for a rescue mission in Sadr City. Mrs Sheehan says she wishes shed driven him to Canada, though thats not what he would have wished and it was his decision. As to whether he died in vain, the Associated Press reported this week:
The capitals Sadr City section was once a hotbed of Shiite Muslim unrest, but it has become one of the brightest successes for the US security effort. So far this year, there has been only one car bombing in the neighborhood, and only one American soldier has been killed.
Cindy Sheehan is a woman whose grief has curdled into a narcissistic rage, and the Democrats cheering her on are cheering their own marginalisation. Most Americans will not follow where shes gone to the wilder shores of anti-Bush, anti-war, anti-Iraq, anti-Afghanistan, anti-Israel, anti-American paranoia. Casey Sheehans service was not the act of a child. A shame you cant say the same about his moms new friends.
It's not often I have to correct Steyn, but Sheehan has always been very "anti-war" (or at least, anti-Bush and by extension anti-any war under Bush's watch); it's just that she is now willing to exploit her son's name to further her cause rather than respect his wishes.
Oh, Myrtle, what a ponce.
marking for later, leisurely read...
Population 690, man I'm itchin to watch Hee-Haw re-runs....lol
The problem for the Democratic party is that the Cindys are now the loudest voice: Michael Moore, Howard Dean, moveon.org, and Air America, the flailing liberal radio network distracting attention from its own financial scandals by flying down its afternoon host Randi Rhodes to do her show live from Camp Casey. The last time I heard Miss Rhodes she was urging soldiers called up for Iraq to refuse to go i.e., to desert and entertaining theories that 9/11 was Bushs Reichstag fire.
On unwatched Sunday talk shows you can still stumble across the occasional sane responsible Dem. But, in the absence of any serious intellectual attempt to confront their long-term decline, all the energy on the Left is with the fringe.
On FNS one of the commentators also said, "This Cindy story is bad for the DomocRATS. It makes the case "Weak on Defense" and it won't stop with the end of summer it will last till the next election."
The more sane and thoughtful among us need to voice our support for honorable and heroic troops serving the highest of ideals, to give the priceless gifts of life and liberty at the risk, and sometimes cost, of their very lives.
I could not have expressed this sentiment better. The leftists' condescension toward our military members is infuriating.
I thought that one deserved repeating.
Add two more names to the list of people I will never pay to see in a movie theater or watch on TV.
Ah, Steyn shines again....
I'm delighted that Cindy has joined the likes of the left lunatic fringe. The Democratic party is in meltdown.
Steyn is correct when he says our soldiers are not the fictitious helpless children that Cindy describes.
Cindy doesn't even seem to care about real small children, those in Iraq.
If Cindy saw an insurgent who was about to kill children with a bomb, and Cindy saw that a soldier had the insurgent in his gunsights, would she tell the soldier to walk away or let the soldier shoot the bomber?
Spot on, as he usually is.
Steyn hits one out of the park yet again.
Absolutely.....they've gone way off the deep end....instead of trying to find a way back to sanity, they continue to recruit ever greater mental radioactives.
Thanks for the ping. Steyn keeps hitting them out of the park.
I think Hillary has already become a laughingstock, even among the few liberals I can associate with. Her election fantasy is just that--fantasy.
Thanks for the ping!!
The funny thing about Mortensen is that, although he is an intense sissy leftist, he will always be remembered for his role as Aragorn - a character that is the complete opposite of his personality and ideology in every way.
Absolutely incredible article.
The left is arrogant, superficial, and negative. The left grasps at any opportunity to patronize serious adults.Whenever Im on a radio show these days, someone calls in and demands to know whether my children are in Iraq. Well, not right now. They range in age from five to nine, and though thats plenty old enough to sign up for the jihad and toddle into an Israeli pizza parlour wearing a suicide-bomb, in most advanced societies armed forces they prefer to use grown-ups.
That's gonna leave a mark . . .
Mark Steyn ping.
Exactly right. So plainly and manifestly did LOTR's storyline support what our President is trying to do, that Mortensen felt obliged to run around telling everyone that it wasn't so, that America is really more like Sauron and the orcs.
Sometimes "idiot" is just too pale a word.
Great article. Thanks!
The same people who want to "Bring our children home" are the same ones who go to abortion clinics so they don't have to "Bring no child home."
I've often thought that people like Mortensen should eb obliged to preface everyt public-policy statement with a disclaimer like this:
"Hi. I'm Viggo Mortensen. I'm not actually a person of character, judgment, morals and accomplishment -- but I played one in a movie. So I'd like to say...."
The great one has spoken. You would think even a lib reading this would see the absurdity in her actions.
Maureen Dowd has long ago traded in any honor she may of had for the handome salary she enjoys by writing political fiction for the left.
Excellent piece, as usual from the brillian Steyn. However, the above statement gives Sheehan too much credit. She was like this BEFORE her son died.
You're welcome ~ Mark always has great stuff to say, even if it takes him time to cover it all. :)
Un-exerpted Steyn BTTT
Everytime I see Sam Waterston from Law and Order do a commercial for TD Waterhouse I tell my wife: "I'm not a certified financial adviser, but I play a district attorney on TV!"
Says it all in a nutshell.
Viggio meets with Cindy
At least you know who they are. I've never heard of them and have never seen either one.
Strongly doubt I'm missing much.
And a big old ping to Mr. Steyn. I remember screaming at my TV last year, when Micky Moore was on O'Reilly and was pushing O'Reilly about sending his "children" to Iraq, that our armed forces were trained professional adults, not a group of six-year-olds!!! Too bad O'Reilly couldn't have said that.
Add two more names to the list of people I will never pay to see in a movie theater or watch on TV."
Who are these people anyway?
Line of the Decade.
True. But Gimli could still kick Aragorn's ass.
Perhaps the Line of the Century.