You may be reading it wrong...the roomie and boyfriend could just have been sitting there, watching TV..and Taylor just decided to give them a little space......most likely it was a ramdom act of violence...forensics on the car will tell a lot..
I don't think we're reading it wrong. I've read it that way every time I've read the story. I don't remember when the girl's disappearance first appeared on Freerepublic some time last week.
That's true.