Posted on 09/25/2005 2:19:08 PM PDT by flixxx
Congressman Charles Rangel of New York, a reasonable man who sometimes goes off the deep end, indulged himself last week. "George Bush is our Bull Connor," he told the Congressional Black Caucus Annual Legislative Conference, referring to the legendary Birmingham, Ala., police chief who attacked peaceful civil rights marchers with dogs and water cannons in 1963. A few minutes earlier, the entertainer Harry Belafonte had read the riot act to Senators Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama.
He said Clinton's proposed commission to investigate the slow governmental response to Hurricane Katrina was "unnecessary" because "we know what caused it"—a veiled reference to white racism and Republican neglect. He said the African Americans in prison were "victims of poverty" and so were the African-American single mothers of children born out of wedlock. And then, just for fun, he added that blacks need to investigate the "ravages of the Democratic Party and see if there's anything worth salvaging."
There is a thin line between righteous and self-righteous anger. An African-American friend, well acquainted with my political impatience, once said, "Joe, if you were black, you'd be in the streets with a machine gun." And so I can sympathize with Rangel and Belafonte—to a point. White racism is the original American sin; it helped create the culture of poverty that exists in places like New Orleans' Ninth Ward. And George W. Bush's dominant Republican Party was reborn in racism, having sided with Southern segregationists in the 1960s. But the tendency of some black baby boomers—the civil rights generation—to attempt to make gains by browbeating white people and ignoring the responsibility of the "victims" themselves has been a total loser. By alienating Middle America, they have helped "ravage" the Democratic Party. Their anger is irrelevant to the questions on the table: What can we as a society do to create opportunities for the poor? And, perhaps more important, how can we regain a national sense of community?
"This is a nation that can go from shock to trance in two weeks," Senator Obama said last week. The current debate on poverty is likely to blow away by the time hurricane season ends. But Katrina and Rita offer those who actually care about poor people a chance to rethink their strategy. Certainly it is time to move beyond victimhood and race-based aggrievement to something more intelligent and inclusive. There are nearly twice as many poor white people living in the U.S. as poor blacks; the black poverty rate diminished dramatically—from 33.4% to 22.5%—during the Clinton Administration (it has risen to 24.7% under Bush); and the recent increase in poverty has been most pronounced among Hispanics. The most effective thing the Congressional Black Caucus could do to fight poverty would probably be to invite white and Hispanic legislators who have significant numbers of poor people in their districts to join its ranks and rename itself the Congressional Antipoverty Caucus. One could also argue that the only way to build a coalition to fight poverty—and preserve affirmative action—in this conservative era would be to base preferences on economic need rather than race.
People like Rangel and Belafonte might do well to listen more closely to the next generation of black leaders—people like Obama and Congressmen Harold Ford of Tennessee, Artur Davis of Alabama and Sanford Bishop of Georgia—who emphasize both the need for more money to fight poverty and the need to change the behavior patterns of the poor. "Our priority has to be with whatever works, as opposed to the conventional wisdom within our group or our party," Obama said last week, adding that liberal and conservative solutions to poverty are not mutually exclusive. "It's not either/or. It's both/and."
It was painful watching Senators Obama and Clinton, both of whom may harbor presidential ambitions, sitting there politely as Belafonte attacked their proposals and their party. Democrats have suffered from a politically correct—and rather condescending—unwillingness to speak truth to anger ever since the civil rights movement turned militant after the death of Martin Luther King Jr. The party has come to seem craven, weak and untrustworthy in the process. The only exception to this pathetic tradition was Bill Clinton's criticism of Sister Souljah's racist rap lyrics during the 1992 presidential campaign, a carefully planned gesture that was compromised by its transparency as a political tactic.
In spontaneous situations, like Belafonte's rant last week, the response is almost always paralytic silence. It would have been quite appropriate and human—and long past time—for either Clinton or Obama to push back, "Harry, do you think we'd have food stamps or Medicaid without the Democratic Party? Didn't you notice how life improved for the working poor after President Clinton passed the earned income tax credit? Tonight, when you're sipping Chablis in your New York City apartment, there will be thousands sleeping on cots in shelters. We're trying to help them. Your anger doesn't help."
Charlie Rangel, "a reasonable man..."???
Sort of.
Joe Klien continues with writing fiction... I especially like the part about how it was the republicans that were the segregationists in the 60s, and how it was racism (and not the "Great Society") that was behind the poverty and breakup of the Black family in the places he mentioned.
Well, I suppose that it is simpler than actually thinking and reasoning.
Mark
No more fish, only the poles!
How about a white caucus? Power to the whitey!
That's as far as I got before I had to stop.
You are correct. Klein totally distorts history. Everyone should make a point of writing Time to correct him.
We have spent roughly seven TRILLION dollars on LBJ's failed "War on Poverty." You always get more of whatever the government subsidizes. It's time to pull the plug on this 30 year war and make people fend for themselves. There are too many fat, lazy, ignorant poor in this country, and we don't need to subsidize more of them.
Klein cannot figure out where he is coming from here.
Wow, and to think people have been just waiting for thousands of years for that little nugget of wisdom. I think you just solved the problem of poverty in the world.
from a George Will column earlier this year
http://jewishworldreview.com/cols/will0901305.asp
""...He might, however, care to note three not-at-all recondite rules for avoiding poverty: Graduate from high school, don't have a baby until you are married, don't marry while you are a teenager. Among people who obey those rules, poverty is minimal.""
I dislike Joe Klein most of the time, because he is a weak sister, and he does nothing but kiss the butts of the favorite Democrat vermin of the moment. But, I must admit he sees what I see, and it the racism of the Harry Belafonte's, Charles Rangel's, John Conyers, Maxine Water's, Cynthia McKinney's, etc. and just about all of the Congressional Black Caucus that has first destroyed any real power that Black folks had, and will help destroy the Democrat Party. I will do everything in my power to make certain that the country understands that it is the Congressional Black Caucus and the NAACP racist and America haters that are now kissing and hugging the likes of Michael Moore and that moron woman, Cindy Sheehan. American Blacks have no idea how their leadership is sinking them as each new day passes. Add to that the growing power of Hispanics, Latinos and Asians, and any objective observer can see Blacks are going nowhere, but to the bottom of the totem pole for a long, long time. Unless the average American Black begins to get it, and dumps the Democrat Party and their present leadership they will remain with a weighty anchor around their quest for political, job & growth opportunity and economic power, mired in the chains of slavery the Democrat Party has forged for them over these last fifty years. Changes are needed right now!!!
my point exactly...even Klein realizes that there must be some responsibility and the old ways are not working...I think this in itself is remarkable.
That is why people who know me best call me simple. :-}
Anti-poverty = Whitey cough it up and give it to poor black folk who will then waste it.
Hey...sometimes the simplest solutions are the best.
Wow, and to think people have been just waiting for thousands of years for that little nugget of wisdom. I think you just solved the problem of poverty in the world.
Well i suppose that could be expanded a little. "If you don't want to be poor, get an education, don't become a drug addict, don't become a criminal and end up with a felony rap sheet, speak english, don't fill your face full on holes, tatoo every square inch of your body, dress conservatively, and get a job."
Notice that this applies to people of all color.
Sounds exactly like what's been happening for 40 years, doesn't it? And it's worked SO well too.
ps - I know you know that, Sterco - but apparently this can't be emphasized/repeated enough.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.