[Always Right]

Do you really believe your own comment that the prebate is "... not a refund because there is no requirement that they pay a dime in taxes ..."? You really think that people would receive the refund and consume zero??

That has been a fairytax arguement used on many occassions. Fairytaxers often claim that people paying sales taxes would be a choice.

[pigdog]

Actually it IS a choice. Perhaps not for you but for mos people. Check with your wife to see if she chooses things when she shops ...