Re "should not make a judgment": The man was found GUILTY of the charge of Negligent Homicide by fellow soldiers who were at the trial and heard all of the testimony, not by me. As far as whether that was the proper verdict I couldn't and didn't "make a judgment, because, like you wrote, I wasn't there. But my point was the PUNISHMENT does not fit the CONVICTION and I stand by that.
You rendered a 'personal' judgment on this matter.