Replies

United 93 is very un-Hollywood.
Spielberg could take some lessons from Greengrass.

January 9, 2006
Reviewer: miat22 (Mia T)

... to borrow a phrase, perversely, from a Spielberg flick about benign intelligence.

Munich, with its false premises, phony pieties and outright lies -- Spielberg fantasy wrapped in sober documentary -- is a verisimilitudinous contrivance that is pernicious, especially now, especially here, especially if we understand Spielberg's real motivation.

Truth matters not at all to Spielberg, and courage matters even less. To advance his fallacious argument, he has Golda Meir speak words she never said, never would have said and, obviously, cannot now disavow. Posthumous misappropriation is a preferred tactic of the abject coward.

Munich is less about Meir avenging the Munich massacre than it is about Bush waging the War on Terror. The historical Munich allusion of appeasement, self-loathing and psychologizing that is practiced so fastidiously by the American Left today is key to understanding Spielberg.

The core of his anti-war argument: By fighting back, we become our enemy. Ironically, with Munich, the same can now be said of Spielberg.

Is Spielberg humanizing the terrorist really any different from Riefenstahl humanizing Hitler? If anything, Spielberg is more contemptible. Whereas Riefenstahl symbolizes the naïve actress and director who is induced to deal with devils, Spielberg is self-actuated and aware.

Hollywood is DreamWorks, fantastical and unthinking and solipsistic by definition.

To mitigate its danger, people capable of critical thinking must take on Hollywood... and must do so in Hollywood venues.

The printed word, sad to say, no longer carries the day.

My New York Times Review of Munich
Was this review helpful to you?
VOTE HERE

.

JOHN PTAK:

-The longtime Creative Artists Agency Agent to the Stars that put together the financing for the stunning "United 93" & upcoming "World Trade Center" Motion Pictures.

-Rancho Alamitos High School, Garden Grove CA, Class of 1960 classmate of "ALOHA RONNIE" Guyer who later became a fellow RICK RESCORLA Veteran of the "WE WERE SOLDIERS" Battle of IA DRANG-1965.

http://www.orgs.cc/RAHS60/ (High School website)

http://www.WeWereSoldiers.com (Paramount Pictures website)

http://www.lzxray.com/guyer_set1.htm (Pictures)

http://www.lzxray.com/guyer_collection.htm (Pictures)

http://www.RickRescorla.com (RICK RESCORLA website)

.