[SJackson]

Just off the top of my head, here are some of the American Jews that I was speaking about in my original post:...I do not say that these are bad people. I believe that they are bad Americans. More, not a single one would last as an Israeli Jew...I do not say that these are bad people. I say that they are loyal Israeli Jews....Golda Meir was a born American and Jewish. What in the world does she have in common with Ruth Bader Ginsburg or Bella Abzug? Nothing. That is my only point.

Precisely, you paint all American Jews as disloyal based on your "examples", which include one Christian with a Jewish father, Pinch Sulzburg.

You alluedee to Irish being bashed because of O'Reilly and Hannity. Can you point to any examples on FR of Irish being denigrated because of either of them?

Are Irish Americans disloyal because a single Irish grandparent entitles them, and successive generations if you register the grandparent, to claim Irish citizenship? Are they worse than Jews since they can claim Irish citizenship from the US without relocating to Ireland.

The whold conversation is absurd.

[ishabibble]

Maybe so, but it's not as bad as your typing!

I posted my reply re this entire thread to Anceshntr. You can read it, but I doubt it will satisfy you.

The disloyal comment is just plain untrue. Go back and check, I never said that. The Irish comments don't merit any answer ,either. When my people came to this country, this became our country.

Winston Churchill was the greatest Englishman in the history of that country. His mother was an American. I believe that a person is what they believe and how they conduct themselves throughout their lives. It has little to do with the way back whens...