Replies

You either need to retract that statement

I'm not retracting a damn thing. Unless and until they come up with or support a proposal to increase controlled legal immigration, it must be presumed that they oppose immigration itself.

The problem isn't immigrants, it's the lack of control over who gets in. It's also the belief, fostered by liberals and machine Democrats who hope to maintain them as voting blocs, that they do not need to assimilate.

-Eric

U.S. immigration rates have ebbed and flowed throughout U.S. history. The idea that there is some kind of inherent right amongst the people of the world to immigrate to America is ridiculous and self-destructive. It doesn't make you more enlightened. It makes you foolish.

Unless and until they come up with or support a proposal to increase controlled legal immigration, it must be presumed that they oppose immigration itself.

So, if someone doesn't support a blanket INCREASE in legal immigration, they are somehow therefore opposed to any existing legal immigration? That is not a logical conclusion.

The Minutemen want to enforce existing laws and secure our border. They do not oppose legal immigration.

"I'm not retracting a damn thing. Unless and until they come up with or support a proposal to increase controlled legal immigration, it must be presumed that they oppose immigration itself. "

The Minutemen are not politicians. Nor do they picket and cause trouble. They came together for one purpose only; to watch the border and report to the propoer authorities any illegals trying to jump the border. Your request for them to, in effect, issue ppolitical "position papers" on immigration is ludicrous!

"I'm not retracting a damn thing. Unless and until they come up with or support a proposal to increase controlled legal immigration, it must be presumed that they oppose immigration itself.
The problem isn't immigrants, it's the lack of control over who gets in. It's also the belief, fostered by liberals and machine Democrats who hope to maintain them as voting blocs, that they do not need to assimilate.

-Eric"

So until YOU come up with a proposal to oppose evil in the world YOU are therefore an 'extremist' who SIDES WITH EVIL ?????

(for your benefit the word 'YOU' above is speaking specificly about you (Eric) whoever you are.)

Hey lets say the same about every other bad thing that you MUST support because you havent publicly made any statement to the contrary.

Maybe you dont realize how dim that kind or reasoning is ?????????????

Using your own logic YOU believe and support Pedophilia, Mass Murder, AND Kitten Strangling (and many many other truly evil things)..... You horrible person you!!!!

Its not their (Minutemens) job to make proposals on anything other than the issue they specificly address -- ILLEGAL immigrants crossing our sieve of a border with little effort (and who knows what else including drug runners and terrorists...)