IMPORTANCE OF ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION TOTAL
..................................Democrat Republican
Extremely Important (30%) 46% 52%
Very Important (32%) ...... 49% 50%
Sixty-two percent said illegal immigration was extremely important or very important - and almost as many Dems felt that way as Republicans.
As you cited with your graph, it's a gradation of many things. If the Repubs had done a better job in one or several of those areas, they would have gotten a pass in the remaining areas. My personal opinion: it sure didn't help that they outspent the Clinton Administration when they had the chance to act like Republicans.