[BenLurkin]

"If tenure can protect incumbents, why can't racial considerations help candidates?"

Any FReeper logicians out there?

Old Ben is certainly no logician but that argument seem really pathetic to me.

[Graybeard58]

"If tenure can protect incumbents, why can't racial considerations help candidates?"

Just typical liberal logic, which means it's not logical at all.

[HarmlessLovableFuzzball]

I am trying to understand Mr Dworkin's motivation here. Is it

1. to introduce more black people to classical music as an alternative to c/rap ?

2. a new liberal social experiment ?

3. an extension of current affirmative action policies?

4. just plain white guilt ?

I suppose I could combine the last three into one.

[GSlob]

Diversity argument in music is cacophonous baboonery. Were it otherwise, this aaron dworkin would by now have a world-class orchestra to show for his trouble. The only way a high-level musician could suddenly and seriously deteriorate is an injury interfering with the ability to perform.

[GSlob]

Diversity argument in music is cacophonous baboonery. Were it otherwise, this aaron dworkin would by now have a world-class orchestra to show for his trouble. The only way a high-level musician could suddenly and seriously deteriorate is an injury interfering with the ability to perform.

[GSlob]

Diversity argument in music is cacophonous baboonery. Were it otherwise, this aaron dworkin would by now have a world-class orchestra to show for his trouble. The only way a high-level musician could suddenly and seriously deteriorate is an injury interfering with the ability to perform.