I went with Innova, but Dick Van Patten's is a good premium brand too. I had some samples, and my kitties scarfed it down. I decided to stay with Innova Evo because I'd already switched, and because it was the only grain-free dry cat food I knew of at the time. But for some reason my critters don't like the canned Innova Evo.
I still want to give my cats at least some human-grade raw food from time to time, and eventually do some homemade stuff just for them.
Whenever I get London Broil on sale (must be under $2.00 per pound for me to buy it, in any case), I cut some up for them... little pieces, along with the blood that seeps out from the meat when it defrosts. The little carnivores love to slurp down the bloody meat!
My oldest one, who was probably fed on nothing but junk food before I got her through a rescue, begs when I prepare chicken, and she cadges tidbits of raw meat. I get a kick out of it, actually. ;)
My cats go crazy for the Dick Van Patten venison and green pea canned.