[ColdWater]

I’m not following you. The leading proponent of ID is against ID? In the words of GW Bush, “That doesn’t make sense.”

He is not against ID. He is the leading proponent of ID.

[Theo]

That’s my point. You’re saying that a leading proponent of ID claims that “ID was dead.” That doesn’t make sense. A “proponent” advocates for something; he doesn’t say it’s dead and worthless.