[ontap]

This part!

I commend you for the first honest attempt to find a solution on the thread yet.

Making them contribute to SS and there by being able to draw from it fixes nothing it simply adds to a problem already out of hand.

[ndt]

"Making them contribute to SS and there by being able to draw from it fixes nothing it simply adds to a problem already out of hand."

OK, first, at this point in my discussion, we re talking about documented guest workers, not illegals.

If these guest workers are paying into SS at the same rate as citizens but not staying into retirement how can they possibly be taking more out then they are paying in?