Posted on 07/11/2007 7:13:29 PM PDT by markomalley
Contracepting the environment Effect of birth-control pills in the poisoning of streams leave environmentalists mum By Wayne Laugesen
7/11/2007 National Catholic Register BOULDER, Colo. (National Catholic Register) When EPA-funded scientists at the University of Colorado studied fish in a pristine mountain stream known as Boulder Creek two years ago, they were shocked. Randomly netting 123 trout and other fish downstream from the citys sewer plant, they found that 101 were female, 12 were male and 10 were strange intersex fish with male and female features.
Its the first thing that Ive seen as a scientist that really scared me, said then 59-year-old University of Colorado biologist John Woodling, speaking to the Denver Post in 2005. They studied the fish and decided the main culprits were estrogens and other steroid hormones from birth-control pills and patches, excreted in urine into the citys sewage system and then into the creek. Woodling, University of Colorado physiology professor David Norris, and their EPA-study team were among the first scientists in the country to learn that a slurry of hormones, antibiotics, caffeine and steroids is coursing down the nations waterways, threatening fish and contaminating drinking water. Since their findings, stories have been emerging everywhere. Scientists in western Washington found that synthetic estrogen a common ingredient in oral contraceptives drastically reduces the fertility of male rainbow trout. Doug Myers, wetlands and habitat specialist for Washington States Puget Sound Action Team, told the Seattle Post-Intelligencer that in frogs, river otters and fish, scientists are finding the presence of female hormones making the male species less male.
This summer, the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service and the American Pharmacists Association will begin a major public-awareness campaign regarding contamination thats resulting from soaps and pharmaceuticals, including birth control. What the Boulder scientists discovered, however, is that few people care. Or, if theyre worried, theyre in denial. Nobody is getting passionately concerned about it, Norris said. It makes no sense to me at all that people arent more concerned. When the story of his finding hit Denver and Boulder newspapers, Norris anticipated an immediate response from environmentalists, who define the politics of Boulder and are known to picket in the streets demanding ends to questionable farming practices, global warming and pesticide treatments. To the professors surprise, however, the hormone story was mostly ignored. Two years later, environmental groups have failed to take up the cause of saving Boulder Creek and its fish from hormone pollution. Dave Georgis, who directs the Colorado Genetic Engineering Action Network, took to the streets of Boulder on several occasions to hold signs demanding that Boulder County regulate genetically modified crops from existence.
When asked about the genetically modified fish and the contaminated drinking water, however, he said: It just has so much competition out there for stuff to work on. He told the Boulder Weekly that nobody needed to consider curtailing use of artificial contraceptives out of concern for the creek. You cant have a zero impact, and this is one of the many, many impacts we have on the environment in everyday life, Georgis said. Nobody is to blame for this, and I dont have a solution. Norris, an environmentalist and birth-control advocate, said that until society achieves better sewage filtration and invents harmless contraceptives, theres always abstinence, and we know that its 100 percent effective. To preserve the self-giving nature of the sexual act, which must always be open to life, the Catechism teaches that it is wrong to use contraception. Couples may space their children for just reasons in ways using natural family planning, which involves observation of signs in the womans body. Says the Catechism: The regulation of births represents one of the aspects of responsible fatherhood and motherhood. Legitimate intentions on the part of the spouses do not justify recourse to morally unacceptable means (for example, direct sterilization or contraception) (No. 2399).
But Catholics shouldnt hold their breath waiting for environmentalists to advocate a boycott of contraceptives, said George Harden, a board member of the Society of Catholic Social Scientists, based in Steubenville, Ohio. If youre killing mosquitoes to save people from the West Nile virus, you can count on secular environmentalists to lay down in front of the vapor truck, claiming some potential side effect that might result from the spray, Harden said. But if birth control deforms fish backed by the proof of an EPA study and threatens the drinking supply, mum will be the word. Harden said the growing knowledge of estrogen-polluted water may expose the cultural double-standards that protect birth control from the scrutiny given to other chemicals and drugs. Its going to start looking funny, Harden said. The radical environmentalist wont eat a corn chip if the corn contacted a pesticide. But they view it a sacred right and obligation to consume synthetic chemicals that alter a womans natural biological functions, even if this practice threatens innocent aquatic life downstream. Despite growing and nationwide knowledge of birth-control pollution in rivers and streams, leading environmentalists remain unfazed even in Boulder, where its been known about for years. Curt Cunningham, water-quality-issues chairman for the Rocky Mountain Chapter of Sierra Club International, worked tirelessly last year on a ballot measure that would force the City of Boulder to remove fluoride from drinking water, because some believe it has negative effects on health and the environment that outweigh its benefits. But Cunningham said he would never consider asking women to curtail use of birth-control pills and patches despite what effect these synthetics have on rivers, streams and drinking water. I suspect people would not take kindly to that, Cunningham said. For many people its an economic necessity. Its also a personal freedom issue. As nonviolence coordinator for the Rocky Mountain Peace and Justice Center, Betty Ball has taken to the streets with signs in protest of genetically modified crops. She lobbies Boulders city and county officials to stop spraying mosquitoes in their effort to fight the deadly West Nile virus a disease that killed seven Boulder residents and caused permanent disabilities in others during the summer of 2004. Right now were worried about weed-control chemicals and pesticides, said Ball, when asked whether her organization would address the hormone problem in Boulder Creek. The water contamination is a problem, but we dont have the time and resources to address it right now.
Norris said hormones have been detected in municipal water supplies, but he said the jurys out on the long-term effects the chemicals might have on humans and human sexuality. Research by New Jersey health officials and Rutgers University scientists found traces of birth-control hormones and other prescription drugs and preservatives in municipal tap water throughout the state in 2003, and they dont know the effects long-term exposure may have. The question is, Is this something the body deals with at low levels, metabolizes and theres no problem? Or is this something that accumulates in the body? We just dont know, said Brian Buckley, the Rutgers chemist who led the four-year drinking water study, reported the North Jersey News. To be honest, we are just starting to deal with the question. Rebecca Goldburg, a New Jersey biologist working with Environmental Defense, told the North Jersey News: Im not sure I want even low levels of birth control pills in my daughters drinking water. Ball said shes alarmed by the sex-altered fish in Boulder Creek, and worries about the ramifications for humans. Unfortunately, it is emerging as a major issue in creeks and waterways all over the earth, and were seeing more and more anomalies, not just with fish but with frogs and other aquatic life. I think its a precursor to what will happen to humans who drink contaminated water, Ball said. Ball said shes shocked that citizens of Boulder havent organized and taken to the streets, as many Colorado environmentalists did upon learning that farmers and agri-businesses were genetically altering crops. She said the major source of contamination thats mutating Boulder Creek fish birth control makes it a political hot potato.
To avoid genetically modified crops, Ball said, one needed only to buy organic, genetically modified organism-free products at health food stores. Asking residents to stop polluting water with hormones, however, gets into the bedroom. Im not going there, Ball said. This involves peoples personal lives, child bearing issues, sex lives and personal choices. Maybe people are saying, O my God, what do we do about this? Apathy is the fear of sticking your toe in, for fear it will change your life, she said. Sometimes positive change does require a change in lifestyle. - - - Wayne Laugesen, based in Boulder, Colo., is a correspondent for National Catholic Register. |
Lot of cattle in Colorado so people are use to BS.
Unfortunately a lot of chemicals, including estrogen byproducts, antibiotics, caffeine, recreational drugs, pharmaceuticals, personal care products, antibacterials, detergents, etc. and all their degradation products, pass right through sewage treatment plants and into receiving streams.
The problem is worst out west where water supplies are limited and ground water resources are heavily used. It is a heck of a problem in the middle east.
For some systems, the sewage effluent is picked up downstream in another city’s drinking water treatment plant intake. In spite of the dilution some concentrations of these pollutants are found in drinking water at effect levels. In Germany there is a saying that the water you drink has been pissed 30 times (in the normal hydrogeologic cycle).
This is not news to the environmental community. The problem is what to do about it. It is extremely expensive to develop wastewater treatment processes that can remove or degrade these chemicals.
If the watermelons can’t get global warming to stick they might take another crack at freaky fish.
This issue comes up every few years. The media runs it up the flag and the public ho hums about it. I don’t think there will be any takers until the next Democratic President/Congress combo happens.
No, but they are drinking water from the Potomac river where the same 'intersex' anomalies are now prevalent in smallmouth bass. Moreover, during the last two or three years, the levels of fecal pollution from municipal waste in the Potomac have gotten so bad that US Park Service employees maintaining and repairing the C&O Canal works are instructed to avoid any skin contact with the water. In effect, the Canal and the river have become open sewers. The bass, bluegills, crappies and perch are mostly gone, leaving carp and a few hardy turtles. Some sort of fix must be in because our shameless leaders in Washington drink and bathe in this stuff, without a murmer.
I rest my case!
... and then there are all the radioisotopes in the waste stream of the local hospital.
.
Fish stream was a poor choice of words, but still one would expect hearing about mutant fish in China, or the Hudson River ;)
Besides soy, health effects from the chemicals contained in plastic milk, etc. containers are blamed for leaching out hormone like substances. Never ends.
LOL, Mexican water! I used to visit TJ frequently to purchase perscription medication. We had no problem chowing down, but we wouldn’t touch the water. Never had a problem, but some folks I knew were horrified that we would eat there.
So how is Baja, in terms of safety? We’re leary about visiting because of all the reports of violence. Also, I heard that one can no longer bring back liquor (among other things), because of new rules.
Hehehe, yes I considered the source :)
I wonder what kind of detergents could be responsible for this? There have been issues made about plastic milk and punch containers leaching chemicals into the product. The chemicals can turn into a hormone like substance. I think the theory had to do with girls reaching puberty at earlier ages.
Now you've done it, I was busy making fun of the post and you had to post the facts.
So what are we going to do about all those little blue pills men are taking.
LOL
Almost all detergents and personal care products contain some type of petroleum-based ingredient. These ingredients are added for a multitude of purposes: preservatives give the product an endless shelf life, solvents 'cut grease', anti-microbials 'kill germs'......the reasons are endless, but ALL of these chemicals are endocrine disruptors, and the ALL wind up going down the drain.
-----
The average person applies over 100 chemicals a day to themselves via personal-care products, and the cosmetics industry that produces those products is not regulated by anything other than itself. The FDA has NO regulatory power over the cosmetics industry.
(For anyone who doesn't believe it, go read the label on your shampoo bottle and Google search a few of the ingredients.)
Most of the time I am near Mexicali, about two hours inland from TJ/San Diego.
How is TJ? There is more violence in TJ and it is more notorious for corruption, especially police corruption. TJ kidnappings and violence are national news in Mexico, consistently. Of course, much of it relates to los narcotraficantes. President Calderon replaced (fired) a few hundred at the head of the branches of the federal police. That is disrupting the government/traficante connection, as is what seems like a cyclical inter-cartel turf battle. “Express kidnappings” round out the major crimes typical of TJ particularly.
There is an election August 5. One of the campaign issues concerns TJ water. Apparently for 40 years politicians have promised potable water in TJ. No results. It now appears, with some political competition, and PAN challenges to PRI one party rule, that TJ may have potable water at some point. Actual infrastructure building, not just talk.
There are better places to visit than TJ as you no doubt already know. But I would suggest trying San Felipe, about 2 hours south of Mexicali on the western shore of the Gulf of Baja. It is experiencing a real estate boom of sorts which I think will end in the next few months, as agents are already pitching permitted but incomplete/failed projects to investors. But it is an interesting “desert meets ocean” environment. Crowded weekends, sleepy during the week.
I do not know about bringing back liquor. However, there are liquor stores in the strip of stores that line the route to the border crossings.
I guess Rompope is too mild for you. But the tequila here gives me a headache. Que lastima.
Move to the shoreline of the Great Lakes!
Enviros aren’t worried about real and solvable problems, they are focussed on politically advantageous anti-capitalist ones.
Nice post!
Wonder what the affect of synthetic estrogen is on the boys who are drinking the water?
Maybe they turn into RINO’s.
“Humanae Vitae” bump
You ain’t gonna believe this BUMP!
I’ll reserve judgment for now. Unfortunately, many Catholic publications just jump right on any negative news about birth control, whether it’s accurate or not.
2399 The regulation of births represents one of the aspects of responsible fatherhood and motherhood. Legitimate intentions on the part of the spouses do not justify recourse to morally unacceptable means (for example, direct sterilization or contraception). |
2370 Periodic continence, that is, the methods of birth regulation based on self-observation and the use of infertile periods, is in conformity with the objective criteria of morality. These methods respect the bodies of the spouses, encourage tenderness between them, and favor the education of an authentic freedom. In contrast, "every action which, whether in anticipation of the conjugal act, or in its accomplishment, or in the development of its natural consequences, proposes, whether as an end or as a means, to render procreation impossible" is intrinsically evil:
|
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.