Posted on 07/21/2007 7:28:09 AM PDT by kellynla
"emotional, emotion"... you must have got the same memo as Sutton and Aguilar. The only hysteria I see are from folks like Johhny Sutton... and your post.
... set aside Court rulings based on the screaming of 5th string talk radio hosts, columns in fringe publications or the various money rasining activist groups e mails.
Actually, I based my opinion on a close reading of the OIG report and the trial transcript, as well as sworn testimony given in front of Congress. Just wondering, do you consider Investor's Business Daily a "fringe publication?"
Never bother to think about that fact do you all?
I think about why some here want to misrepresent the facts as the documents mentioned lay out.
That ALL your information on this case is presented by tainted sources with a political ax to grind here? NO, because it fits your hyper emotional position on Illegal Immigration, you just accept as “facts” anything that fit your emotional whimsy
NO. Most are not basing their opinions on that, as mentioned above. "Tainted... ax... hyper emotional position... emotional whimsy... " That sounds a bit hysterical to me. ;-)
Well guess what. It possible for Border Patrol Agents to be thugs and crooks. Just because they serve in the Border Patrol doesn’t make them saints.
Well, duh! Unfortunately, that has been shown to not be the case in this instance.
Bush comuted Libby’s sentence so he could stay out of jail pending the appeals process. But that process is still going forward.
And he argued that he would not step in on the Ramos/Compean case until the appeals process had been completed. Double standard?
He did not over rule the legal system just to appease the emotional whisy of various far right pressure groups. That is what you all are demanding here.
There you go again with that "emotional whisy" (sic) stuff. Get a grip!
Bush, quite simply, cannot be trusted.
Absolutely right. Bush has been in a coma for over a year now. He just doesn't get it that these two agents were convicted by a kangaroo court laced with a jury that has the intelligence of a monkey. Sorry, I didn't mean to insult monkeys.
There used to be Rockefeller Republicans, Taft Republicans, Eisenhower Republicans, Goldwater Republicans, Reagan Republicans. Now there are Sutton Republicans!!!!
Ramos and Compean’s problems is that they are not among the elites to whom GWB caters — elites in both parties too.
Yes, I guess the late Molly Ivins was right after all. But what is bizarre is that Molly disliked GWB when he stands for nearly everything that she did.
Actually, he got kicked upstairs after he got the conviction. I believe he remains in that post.
03/08/2006 Jury trial concludes. Jury votes to convict on all counts except Count 1, Assault with Intent to Commit Murder.03/28/2006 DOJ Press Release, 3/29/2006 U.S. Attorney Johnny Sutton appointed by Alberto Gonzales to serve as chair for the Attorney General's Advisory Committee a role "which plays a significant role in determining policies and programs of the Department and in carrying out the national goals set by the President and the Attorney General."
“It possible for Border Patrol Agents to be thugs and crooks?”
The government prosecuted Ramos and Compean criminally for acts that called only for an administrative reprimand, based the case on the testimony of an admitted drug smuggler brought back from Mexico and induced to testify by a grant of immunity, withheld crucial evidence from the jury, used the wrong law (that carries a mandatory additional 10-year sentence), and now won’t release the transcript of the trial without which the border guards cannot appeal.
The smuggler’s reward for his testimony was immunity, U.S. medical treatment, and a government-issued border pass.
Meanwhile, the Department of Homeland Security now admits that its official lied to congressmen in claiming that Ramos and Compean had confessed, lied, destroyed evidence, and said they did not believe the smuggler was a threat. No evidence ever existed for those damaging accusations.
The government denied their freedom pending appeal and put Ramos in a prison where five criminal illegal immigrants were alleged to have severely beat him and kicked him with steel-toed work boots. Reportedly, no prison guards defended him from this attack.
The prosecutor, U.S. Attorney Johnny Sutton, claims that Ramos shot an unarmed drug smuggler in the rear end as he was running away. But the ballistics report failed to prove the bullet came from Ramos’ gun, and the medical report showed that the bullet entered the smuggler’s buttock on his side at an angle consistent with Ramos’s contention that the smuggler was turning around with what looked like a weapon in his hand.
Ramos and Compean didn’t believe they wounded the smuggler because he kept running and escaped across the border into a waiting vehicle. The doctor’s description of the trajectory of the bullet he removed from the smuggler’s body casts doubt on the whole assumption that his wound came from shots fired by the border guards.
Sutton claims that Ramos and Compean were prosecuted because they “lied” and covered up their actions. The alleged lie was that they gave an incomplete report of their confrontation with the smuggler on Feb. 17, 2005.
As usual, your blathering is based on fiction.
Screw Bush and Sutton!
-—Laura Ingraham emphasized how stupid this “my friend, Johnny Sutton” remark is. How stupid Jorge Bush is on this issue, and all issues dealing with his friends, the Mexican criminals.-—
My wife has been telling be from the beginning that George Bush is stupid. I have always countered that that is just not really possible, nor is it possible that he’s crazy. Lately I have been countering with the Peggy Noonan judgement, that what seems to be lacking is wisdom. In the end though, that is not really very convincing, is it?
More and more, I’m just seeing someone who is completely out of their depth. It’s like watching an average golfer play in the Masters, not enough understanding, not enough skill, not enough control, and not enough wisdom to just step back.
Mr. Sutton also serves as the chairman of the Attorney General’s Advisory Committee (AGAC) which plays a significant role in determining policies and programs of the Department and in carrying out the national goals set by the President and the Attorney General.
The AGAC consists of 17 members appointed by the Attorney General and represents different judicial circuits, various-sized offices, and expertise. Mr. Sutton also serves on the Border and Immigration Law Enforcement Subcommittee of the AGAC.
Prior to becoming United States Attorney, Mr. Sutton served as an Associate Deputy Attorney General at the U.S. Department of Justice in Washington, D.C., and as a Policy Coordinator for the Bush-Cheney Transition Team assigned to the Department of Justice.
Mr. Sutton served as the Criminal Justice Policy Director for then-Governor George W. Bush from 1995-2000, advising the Governor on all criminal justice issues, with specific oversight in the areas of criminal law, prison capacity and management, parole operations and legislative initiatives.
Prior to his service in the Governor’s office, Mr. Sutton worked as a criminal trial prosecutor in the Harris County District Attorney’s Office (Houston, Texas) for eight years. As a prosecutor, he was lead trial counsel in over sixty felony cases, including numerous capital murder, aggravated robbery, and sexual assault cases. He is fluent in Spanish, having appeared as a television commentator for the Spanish language network Univision during the Selena homicide trial.
Mr. Sutton is a graduate of the University of Texas at Austin, where he earned a bachelor’s degree in International Business in 1983, and the University of Texas School of Law, where he earned his Juris Doctor degree in 1987. As an undergraduate, he played baseball for the Longhorns and was the starting left-fielder on the 1983 National Championship team.
Johnny Sutton
United States Attorney
Western District of Texas
601 N.W. Loop 410, Suite 600
San Antonio, Texas 78216
Telephone (210) 384-7400
Libby was a friend of Cheney who is a friend of Bush. Sutton is a friend of Bush. Sorry, Ramos and Compean just don’t have friends in high enough places.
Bush makes me sick here. Pardon them already!
Here is Sen. John Cornyn's legal stats from his DC website.
As Texas Attorney General from 1999-2002, John Cornyn directed many initiatives vital to the interests of Texas families. Cornyn served for six years as a District Court Judge in San Antonio before being elected to the Texas Supreme Court in 1990, where he served for seven years.
Now here is US Attorney Johnny Sutton's stats from his DoJ website.
Prior to becoming United States Attorney, Mr. Sutton served as an Associate Deputy Attorney General at the U.S. Department of Justice in Washington, D.C., and as a Policy Coordinator for the Bush-Cheney Transition Team assigned to the Department of Justice.
Mr. Sutton served as the Criminal Justice Policy Director for then-Governor George W. Bush from 1995-2000, advising the Governor on all criminal justice issues, with specific oversight in the areas of criminal law, prison capacity and management, parole operations and legislative initiatives.
Prior to his service in the Governor’s office, Mr. Sutton worked as a criminal trial prosecutor in the Harris County District Attorney’s Office (Houston, Texas) for eight years.
Now tell me, after reading these two biographies, who is more political? Who has better credentials? I would say Sen. Cornyn is better able to "judge" the conduct of the Ramos-Compean trial. And he agrees with Sen. Feinstein that Sutton overreached.
Pres. Bush attempted to demean those who opposed his amnesty by saying they didn't know what was best for America. He is now attempting to obscure a miscarriage of justice by saying opponents are emotional. For him to defend Johnny Sutton by saying he is a "dear friend" simply shows how tone deaf he is to the views of middle class Americans. Especially those of us who strongly believe that the rule of law, FAIRLY applied, is essential to the future of this country.
I would repeat an earlier comment that the President must choose between friendship and justice. I pray that justice wins, but I am not optimistic that justice will come via this President.
As an interesting foot note, this also from Sutton's bio:
He is fluent in Spanish, having appeared as a television commentator for the Spanish language network Univision during the Selena homicide trial.
Yep.
I guess I can’t commit to vote republican then either.
Jorge has more than just a scope up his backside today.
Libby was convicted. But I don’t Bush saying “listen to the facts Fitzgerald lays out”. He said Libby’s 30-month prison sentence was too harsh, but I guess 10 years for doing really nothing is just right.
Less than 18 months left until Bush leaves. Thank God.
Bush commuted Libby's sentence so he could stay out of jail period you frickin' moron. There is no "stay out of jail while appeals process goes on." There is an on-going appeals process in regards to Libby, but no matter what happens with the appeal, he ain't going to prison.
“Bush referred to the U.S. attorney responsible for the case, Johnny Sutton, as “a dear friend of mine” and called him a “fair guy” and “even-handed,” according to a White House transcript.”
Translation: Sutton did my dirty work for me, so I could appease the Mexican Govt. No pardons!
“I’ve been critical of W’s communication content, skills, and delivery process for years, only to be flamed by bush-bots”
Most of them are gone now : )
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.