Posted on 08/06/2007 6:33:43 AM PDT by Esther Ruth
22 Av 5767, August 6, '07
Published: 08/06/07, 10:59 AM / Last Update: 08/06/07, 12:05 PM
Elite IDF Soldiers Refuse Hevron Expulsion Orders, Face Trial
by Hana Levi Julian
(IsraelNN.com) IDF Central Commander Maj.-Gen. Gadi Shamni removed two unit commanders and 10 other soldiers from their positions in the elite Duchifat unit on Monday after they refused to participate in the expulsion of two Jewish families from their homes in the former Hevron marketplace.
Shamni said the soldiers will face a disciplinary trial for their actions. "This is a phenomenon that endangers the very base the IDF stands on," he said. "This is an army of the people, and in a democratic nation soldiers must obey orders."
Some 30 IDF soldiers refused to board the bus Monday morning after being told by officers that their orders to carry out operations in Judea and Samaria included the forcible eviction of two families from their homes in the former Hevron marketplace.
An unidentified father of one of the Duchifat soldiers who balked at carrying out the order stated “the soldiers are standing with determination in their refusal to participate in any part of the expulsion of Jewish families from Hevron.” Another father, Moshe Rosenfeld, said in an interview on Army Radio “My son didn’t join the army to expel Jews, but to defend them. Furthermore, this is not an operation for the army, but for the police.”
The Duchifat unit is a special counter-terrorism battalion in the Kfir Brigade of the IDF Central Command infantry division. The Kfir Brigade is the largest such unit in the IDF, and includes Netach Yehuda and Nachal Hareidi forces. Duchifat soldiers specialize in urban combat and usually operate in the Ramallah area, with the responsibility for the protection of Jewish communities which include Beit El, Ofra and others.
A number of the soldiers who refused to get on the bus are students of Rabbi Chaim Druckman, who is guiding them through the process.
NRP / NU Knesset member Tzvi Hendel stated flatly in another broadcast interview, “There is no limit to the stupidity of the government…. Just as a soldier must think before shooting at an Arab, so too should one should think here as well. I understand a soldier who says that he is unable to carry out this order,” he added.
“I am not talking about refusal. It’s not enough to simply say that you’re following orders. We are not a dictatorship….We are not talking about soldiers refusing to fight in a war, but in soldiers refusing to carry out a political operation, which is not the mission of the IDF.”
Peace Now Secretary Yariv Oppenheimer asserted, "The extreme right is trying to turn the army into a political game. The IDF should not lend a hand to these attempts." The extreme left-wing activist insisted that soldiers who refuse to follow orders to expel the two families from their homes should be arrested and face a court trial.
A spokesman for the Rabbinical Council of Judea and Samaria commented, “The army shouldn’t be drafting children of Judea and Samaria to throw their families out of their homes.” There were a number of such instances during the 2005 Disengagement operation, when more than 8,000 Jews were expelled from 25 vibrant communities in the Gush Katif region of Gaza, and northern Samaria.
Meretz Knesset member Avshalom Vilan said that refusing IDF orders not the purview of the soldiers and officers. “They are meant to carry them out,” he stated.
The IDF is set to deploy some 3,000 soldiers for the effort to expel the two families, including 14 children, from their homes on Tuesday. The former Hevron marketplace is adjacent to the Avraham Avinu neighborhood, from which nine families and a yeshiva were evicted a year and a half ago.
At that time, commander of Judea and Samaria forces IDF General Yair Golan convinced the families to leave, by promising that they would be allowed to return soon after with an improved legal status. The government reneged on the deal shortly thereafter when Attorney General Menachem Mazuz ruled that Golan did not have the authority to make the deal.
Four coalition Knesset members, three opposition Knesset members and two ministers signed a letter sent to Defense Minister Ehud Barak last week urging him to reconsider the order. "The residents in Hevron prevented a clash such as that in Amona when they removed themselves from their homes based on promises that they would be able to return," read the letter in part. "This approach must be encouraged, not put down."
Hevron officials say they are once again being promised that if they leave willingly a quiet return to the marketplace will be arranged in the future. A similar episode took place with the Beit Shapira House, wich remains sealed and empty to this day.“We've been through that one too many times,” said Hevron community spokesman David Wilder. “The property is Jewish property. A military appeals court recommended that the buildings be leased to the Hebron Jewish community. This too was rejected. What more do they want?”
In the aftermath of the War of Independence in 1948, Jordan occupied Hebron and gave control of the marketplace to the Custodian of Abandoned Properties.
The market was leased to the Hebron Municipality, which allowed the merchants to stay. That situation continued after Israel reclaimed the area in 1967.
Wilder continued, stating that it was “illogical to ask Jewish families to leave property that was owned by Jews, in the name of an empty marketplace that had not been operational for 13 years, and for which there was no plan to release to Palestinian merchants.”
Ze'ev Orenstein and Nissan Raztlav-Katz contributed to this article.
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/Flash.aspx/131196
13:25 PM 22 Av 5767, August 6, ‘07
Women in Green: Expelling Jews No Longer in Our Lexicon
(IsraelNN.com) In response to the refusal of 30 soldiers from the Duchifat battalion to take part in the expulsion of two Jewish families from the marketplace in Hevron, Women in Green issued a statement in support of the soldiers.
“After Gush Katif, the expulsion of Jews is no longer in our lexicon. Our soldiers have learned their lesson and have declared: Never again!”
I would not expell the Jews from Hebron. That is where Abraham, Isaac and Jacob are buried. Jacobs other name was Israel. God , himself , said so.
IDF Central Commander Maj.-Gen. Gadi Shamni removed two unit commanders and 10 other soldiers from their positions in the elite Duchifat unit on Monday after they refused to participate in the expulsion of two Jewish families from their homes in the former Hevron marketplace.
Without commenting on weather the removel is the correct thing to do or not, I’ll say good. Soldiers don’t get to choose which orders they have to obey.
Those soldiers however are on God’s side.
Are you saying the Israeli people are against God?
Are you saying the Israeli people are against God?
The Olmert Government is against God’s plans. The scriptures clearly say that the lands belong to the jews.
When the Israeli Government gives it away it’s against God’s plans. This of course assumes that one believes in the holy scriptures. I matter of factly do.
A majority of Israelis might have elected Olmert, but his ratings are very very low and it’s rather obvious that the Zionists will win the next elections.
Your comment is a classic example of something that may be true..but irrelevent.
I had a flight chief in Korea who would sy “You don’t have to like it..you do however have too do it.....or I can make you wish you had.”
“Are you saying the Israeli people are against God?”
The government and the system are imperfect, as with any government of man, since the beginning of time.
I had family in the Gush and family in the IDF/police at the same time; the entire process is disgusting.
“I had a flight chief in Korea who would sy “You don’t have to like it..you do however have too do it.....or I can make you wish you had.””
The soldiers should expect, and receive, punishment, for they are breaking the law of the land.
That does not mean, however, that they are not acting correctly in the eyes of God.
Daniel faced much the same quandry when he refused to worship the king.
Daniel was properly punished, for he broke the law of the land.
But, as with Daniel, God will take care of those who break the law, to follow Him.
Israeli politicians now wish to promulgate a policy that states a soldier should always follow his orders.
Ironic, no?
Warning! This is a high-volume ping list.
The ones which should be on trail are Olmert & Peres.
That's what the Nazis said. "We were only following orders".
G-d said that in the end of days He would re-gather His people into His Land.shalom b'shem Yah'shuaThose who remove the Jews from the land that G-d gave them will be punished.
Whether it be Sharon, Bush, Rice, Olmert or Peres.
God bless those Soldiers for doing what is right instead of what is politically expediant.
Good Soldiers will do what is right regardless of orders.
It’s called Moral courage.
The Waffen SS was full of REALLY good soldiers who obeyed orders to the letter, regardless of the moral right or wrong of those orders.
I hope our own troops have the moral courage to do what is right if our tyrannical federal government ever decides to turn them on the civilian population of this country.
“So the Jews have suffered immeasurably at the hands of soldiers whose only defense was “We were just following orders.””
Sounds frighteningly familiar doesn’t it.
re: Nuremburg
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.