We implemented a testing program in Colorado and it has been an invaluable tool for parents and has provided performance data to make adjustments.
While I understand the need for a pay for performance type system, the fundamental question is “what is the role of the government”.
First, I do not believe that the Federal government should be sending money to school districts for education ... but that is a topic for a different thread.
Second, I do believe that the government should be establishing standardized testing for a nationally recognized HS diploma.