So now I strike Duke and W&M from the college list for my daughter. No credibility.
I respect your process in eliminating Duke and W & M. You are thinking the right thoughts.
I have a child at W & M and the fight is actually going pretty well there. The students have so far successfully fought off the NCAA initiative to force them to drop their team name, fought off a move to closet a historically significant cross that was being displayed in a building and generally been alert to PC totalitarianism on the part of the faculty and administration.
Make sure you actually familiarize yourself with the politics and moral atmosphere of the campus you choose, because W & M was about the best that we could do.