bttt
If I understood this guy’s theory: As the plane was crashing in 2004, it entered the time warp (or whatever) and crashed on the Island in 1996. When the 6 finally make it off the Island, they learn that in real (later to be claimed it was 8). So when they keep saying only 8 survived the crash, they feel guilty because in their time travel reality they know others survived, but in real time they did not?