When you try to execute people without a judge, that is likely to happen.
Execute people after being tried by a military commission in Guantanamo. Are you against this? A simple yes or no will suffice. I have no problem with it
But we have three choices: 1. fair trial. 2. Mock trial. 3. Summary execution. SECNAV is doing his best to avoid option 1, and he cannot do option 3 so he is doing his damndest to get option 2, just like for the Haditha Marines.
You missed off the key quibble that has lead to all the litigation.... tried by a military commission that flying in the face of all precedent, is not headed by an impartial [military if you wish] judge to conduct the trial. The process for military tribunals is as old as the hills. Why did this administration decided to go off on a flier and attempt to rewrite the whole thing.