WTH, this is just one guy who signed onto NR and posted his comment on their blog.
Not at all. He’s a contributing editor to the National Review.
http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=YThjYTU1ZDBjNmQ2YzcwNzU1MmYwN2JiMWY0ZGI0NDA=
He’s very legitimate.
I just went and checked, and the post IS from Andy McCarthy, a regular contributor to NR and a generally solid conservative. He may be wrong on whether McCain is dead or not, but he makes some valid points about what McCain has to do to win this thing.