[Huck]

Except that in this case, there are still just as many tomatoes at the stand when they leave. Oops, doesn't fit your "stealing" paradigm very well...

Incorrect. A downloaded song that was not paid for is a loss of revenue. It's stealing. I love how you thieves squirm at the reality of your deeds. Just admit it. You're a petty thief.

[Sloth]

Incorrect. A downloaded song that was not paid for is a loss of revenue.

This is only true if the choice is between obtaining the song for free or obtaining the song by purchase. That's a false dilemma. The third choice is not obtaining the song at all (which is, after all, what most people do). Compared to that, the 'content provider' loses nothing to downloading.

I love how you thieves squirm at the reality of your deeds. Just admit it. You're a petty thief.

Interesting. I have not stated that I illegally download songs at all. What is your evidence?