Posted on 11/07/2009 8:15:05 PM PST by TenthAmendmentChampion
Back in 1989, the Democrat House, led by Ways and Means Chairman Dan Rostenkowski, passed the ‘Catastrophic Health Care Act.’ The Act promised to expand coverage and benefits, financed by a surcharge on senior’s existing Medicare benefits. Passage of the Act sparked on outcry from seniors. CBSNews goes back into the archives to find footage of one of the protests.
The report forgets to mention that Congress quickly repealed the Catastrophic Act in response to the voter backlash. Something current Members of Congress might want to keep in mind.
The problem for today’s Democrats is that the PelosiCare bill they are being pressured to support has a lot more to anger seniors than just a modest surcharge. Between the cuts to Medicare and numerous higher taxes, more people will lose under this bill than gain. That’s very dangerous politics. Again, if a small surcharge, in exchange for more benefits, was enough to spark protests that rattled on Old Bull like Rostenkowski, imagine the backlash when seniors realize they will lose lots of benefits in exchange for…nothing. Rostenkowski was genuinely surprised by the protests. After Tuesday’s elections results, however, Democrats can’t say they weren’t warned.
Below is a list of the cuts to Medicare contained within PelosiCare:
(Excerpt) Read more at biggovernment.com ...
IF there is enough voter backlash in 2010 they may very well repeal it.
Just wait until the people actually get a look at what just passed. AARP is going to regret the day they sold out to Obama along with the AMA.
Now it is on to the Senate where Dr. Coburn is saying he will read all of the Reid bill on the floor with help which will delay it for months.
Why the rush to pass a bill that doesn’t take effect til 2013. Four years from now.
Repeal is imminent.
Mark my words, healthcare will never ever be repealed.
“Why the rush to pass a bill that doesn’t take effect til 2013. Four years from now.
Repeal is imminent.”
Show me one example of a government entitlement that has been taken away once it is started.
Pray for civil war.
So the people won’t feel the pain until after the next election, and so they can collect from us for years before any benefits are actually paid.
Memory lane ping!!! (House passes a total “in your face” to Seniors in truly un-American fashion!!!)
A change in Congressional make-up next year could do it.
Also, this entitlement doesn’t accrue to any voter till 2013. This entitlement doesn’t exist for another 4 years.
But you are right no entitlement given has been taken away, to my knowledge.
How does one uncare? It hurts too much to care anymore. I hate my country.
From what I read and heard on the radio, the taxes doesn’t take effect till 2013 either.
Gosh, makes a person really miss old Rostenkowski...back from the era when stealing from the stamp drawer and petty cash was considered “corruption”. Nowadays, Obama appoints guys much worse than him to Cabinet positions!
Anything that’s passed by Congress can be repealed by Congress. I hope.
Yes! Repeal the bill in 2010! Work against every House fool who voted for this travesty!
“Anything that’s passed by Congress can be repealed by Congress. I hope.”
Not as long as Dumbo is in the White House unless you get a 2/3 majority in both houses!
“Work against every House fool who voted for this travesty!”
And the Democrats that voted against it. These guys were given permission to take cover. They are not principled heros. They need to be defeated as well
“A change in Congressional make-up next year could do it.
Also, this entitlement doesn’t accrue to any voter till 2013. This entitlement doesn’t exist for another 4 years.
But you are right no entitlement given has been taken away, to my knowledge.”
I see no other solution than civil war, and people are too fat, dumb and happy to make that happen at this point. So just bend over and take it.
“From what I read and heard on the radio, the taxes doesn’t take effect till 2013 either.”
The tax starts in 2010. The cram down starts in 2013
You sound like my husband, Freddd. I have been terrified of this bill... earlier tonight I priced dialysis machines. Imagine my delight at finding them less than $2500! My insurance pays $1000 per treatment. I could do my own dialysis with some help. I could save Blue Shield $100K per year. I wonder if this is what the British folks do...
In 1979 then president Smiley Carter created the Dept. of Education; since then we’ve had not one, but three Republican presidents and Republican majorities in Congress off and on. We haven’t managed to remove this parasite from the cabinet. Just a thought.
This, if it succeeds in the Senate, is going to be a terribly bitter pill for Seniors who benefit greatly from Medicare Advantage plans and I know my Medicare eligible clients are going to learn the whole awful story from me!!!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.