Posted on 11/19/2009 6:09:21 PM PST by cold start
There’s the cliched phrase: “It’s like watching a train wreck.” In “Terror in Mumbai,” which airs tonight 8 pm ET/PT on HBO, you get to see what no documentary has shown before: a “360 degree view” of a multi-pronged terrorist act, seen partly and genuinely from the terrorists point view. The reason: “Terror in Mumbai” uses actual cell phone instructional conversations during the attack given to the terrorists in the field by a shadowy control “boss” in Pakistan. Not recreated -- the real thing…and it will make your blood both boil, and freeze.
So, yes, even terrorists have “directors” who guide and supervise their every move as they do their dirtywork. It shows how the terrorists got info on where Indian security forces were heading and specific directions on which hostages to kill and when — even when to throw hand grenades and set hotel fires.
One of the most chilling moments: where the control agent in Pakistan talks to a hostage at the Jewish center in Mumbai and reassures her she could be home “by Sabbath.” You hear the fear in her voice. Later on he orders the terrorist to murder her and another hostage. You hear the shots (the boss in Pakistan wanted to stay on the phone to personally hear the murders himself).
Another feature: extensive and stunning footage of the Indian police interrogation of the lone surviving gunman in his hospital bed, answering all of their questions, weeping because he realized he had been duped (it’s later reported in the documentary that his trainers/handlers told him that when he died his body would smell like flowers as he went to heaven…so Indian officials took him to the morgue to show him the dead bullet ridden bloated bodies of the other 9 gunmen which was a huge shock to him).
Produced and directed by Dan Reed, “Terror in Mumbai” uses parts of 284 intercepted cell phone calls, news footage, still photos, extensive video surveillance photos of the terrorists in action, interviews with police officials — plus interviews with guests from the Taj Mahal and Oberoi hotels who detail the mass executions there — to give a moment-by-moment reconstruct the horrific November 26, 2008 events where 10 not-so-heavily-armed gunmen paralyzed a city and stunned the world as images were beamed worldwide on the tube. “Terror in Mumbai documents how, as the murders were reported and images of fires emerged, the control agent in Pakistan was almost giddy at the carnage-created publicity unfolded on his TV screen.
After hijacking a ship and slitting the captain’s throat (Terrorist: “We finished him off. We slit his throat.”), the terrorists spread out in the city to attack Mombai’s main railway station, a popular cafe, two major hotels and a Jewish center. HBO and Reed also picked a class act to narrate the piece, Mumbai-born Fareed Zakaria, who is as superb a narrator as he is Editor of a Newsweek’s International Editor and as a CNN host. During the documentary, Zakaria says the following:
“Much as the 9/11 attacks in the U.S. did in 2001, the events that unfolded last November in Mumbai served as a terrifying wake-up call, not just to India but to the rest of the world…It broadened the spectrum of our enemies and brought attention to the number of different terrorist groups that exist, who may be bigger and better organized than we ever imagined. The fact that a small group of gunmen was able to inflict so much pain, and the government of the second most populous nation on earth was unable to stop them for three days, should change our sense of the dangers out there.”
In fact at one point, the control agent tells one of the doomed terrorists:“This was just the trailer. Just wait till you see the rest of the film.”
Some highlights that linger: # Police were incompetent. Some 25 police stood by at the rail station and watched two terrorists butcher men, women and children – -and then fled. There was no police plan in Bombay to deal with this kind of attack. # The specific instructions from the handler in Pakistan — as the handler often talked to someone even higher up in the background — about murdering innocents. It’s as if they are putting in an order of shampoo online. “Yes do it. Site them up and shoot them in the back of the head….Tell them this is just a taste…” He frames it as “a struggle between Islam and the unbelievers.” # Proof that terrorists are doing murder stagecraft. At several points the control agent talks about how an ordered bloody act will “make them afraid.” # The haunting images of the survivors, most of them speaking their regular language with subtitled translations: a Turkish couples grief as they talked about being spared due to their religion and watching the terrorists butcher others including a young woman weeping from Singapore who was only in the city for one hideous day; a young boy who lost 6 relatives including his father and mother and cannot understand why someone would hate so much — and kill so much. # The anti-semetic component in the attack on the Jewish Center. When Jews say “never again” they might use these words uttered by the control agent in Pakistan as motivation: he says that “killing a Jew is worth 50″ guests murdered in the Oberoi Hotel. # The youth and naive nature of the terrorists, mostly Paksitanis from rural areas. Even as they are firing their rifles like toy guns and snuffing out lives and destroying the lives of families, they are virtually oohing and ahhing over the hotel’s opulence (stained glass windows! all those computers!) as their control agent tries to keep them on task. # The role of the media in terrorism. “Terror in Mumbai” shows, with archival footage coupled with the comments of the bigwigs directing the terrorists in Pakistan, how terrorist bosses can kick back and enjoy their work on TV and revel in the FEAR.
More than any documentary, “Terror in Mumbai” hammers home the horror, grief and brutality of terrorism. But more than that: taken altogether it illustrates perfectly what “terrorism” means not to just those on the receiving end of it as victims or responders, but to the terrorists themselves.
Some reviews have raised eyebrows about “humanizing” the terrorists. But this piece is one of the best illustrations of the problem: terrorist recruiters use perverted definitions of faith to rope in young people who aren’t sophisticated and not exactly rocket scientists to begin with (which is good because they’d probably use the rockets they manufactured if they were). When they’re kicking down a hotel door to find guests to mercilessly butcher, it’s their mission to increase the body count. And, they are told and themselves parrot, they are destined for a great place in heaven for snuffing out the lives of anyone, regardless of gender or age.
And the control agent makes it crystal clear: the mission is not over until he terrorist is killed.
But here is the scariest part:
The Mumbai attacks, documented so comprehensively in this documentary indeed should serve as a wake up call.
This kind of multi-pronged attack could be replicated in almost any city including in the Untied States. Zakaria notes: “By attacking multiple targets the terrorists had hoped to plunge the police into chaos. They succeeded completely.”
Are U.S. cities prepared?
On a TMV scale of one to five, “Terror in Mumbai” gets a six stars.
“This kind of multi-pronged attack could be replicated in almost any city including in the Untied States.”
yes it could. Two differences..
1) the cops in the US have guns AND bullets
2) a good number of the people are also carrying guns with bullets.
1) & 2) are the definition of the terms “A well-regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State...”
Islam in a nutshell.
“a struggle between Islam and the unbelievers.”
Was the control agent in Pakistan apprehended?
US convert David Headley, the terror scumbag arrested in Chicago has been implicated in the Mumbai Massacre.
The investigation is ongoing and very complex.
Headley is not a convert, he changed his name from Daood Gilani to a christian name to hide his Pakistani origins.
Thank you, I thought it was the other way around.
Lashkar-e Toiba(LeT) which carried out this attack has deep connections to and was actually set up by Pakistan’s ISI(Intelligence agency). The Pakistanis arrested a few guys but they haven’t actually done anything more and knowing their deep connections with LeT, there is no real belief that they will do anything but obfuscate and stall the investigations on one pretext or the other..
Those of you, like me, who have a state handgun carry permit, need to be armed, always.
No - we will be caught with our pants down - maybe across our 50 states in a day of carnage - because we are not prepared. But they will only be able to do this once. That is why I hope and pray that the futility of any such effort will prevent it from happening.
Oh, BTW, we could be prepared - but nobody will do anything until we're attacked again. If we're attacked at many sites (Al-queda hallmark) only the police can respond - anyone else is arguably a bad guyu/terrorist and as always when seconds count ... the police are only minutes away. We are so vulnerable I shudder. Sorry. Happy Thanksgiving.
Indian intelligence had been able to get some simms chips into the hands of the Army of the Righteous in Pakistan. The terrorists had activated three of them the morning before the attacks started. Subsequently, the "controller" and attackers's conversations are heard frequently on the documentary.
The attackers were mostly boys and young men who had been bought from their families. The surviving attacker said for 240,000, but didn't mention type of currency.
Of course, there are ample doses of Peace, Heaven, God Willing and the usual jihadi rhetoric we have seen and heard so many times before.
That muzzie son of a whore in the WH is doing the same thing to the economy.
Yes, because he was named by the surviving attacker. He is supposedly getting a “private trial.” The documentary said the Army of the Righteous originally started out to fight in Kashmir, but is now out of government control (that’s what they said) and has assimilated into various areas of Pakistani culture countrywide.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.