Posted on 12/16/2009 6:28:30 AM PST by NYer
.- Actor Sam Elliot has blamed the Catholic Church for stopping sequels from being made to the Golden Compass movie based on the first book of Philip Pullman’s atheistic trilogy His Dark Materials. The film, starring Nicole Kidman, Daniel Craig and Eva Green, grossed more than $380 million worldwide after its Christmas 2007 release, but took in only $85 million in the U.S. According to the Internet Movie Database, the film had a budget of $180 million.
The 65-year-old Elliot, who played a Texan “aeronaut” in the film, charged that a Catholic-led campaign against the movie stopped its sequels from being made.
“The Catholic Church happened to The Golden Compass, as far as I'm concerned,” Elliot remarked to the Evening Standard.
He said the movie did “incredible” at the box office but the Catholic Church “lambasted” the filmmakers and “scared off” New Line Cinema executives.
The movie itself is about a young heroine named Lyra who fights against an evil organization called the Magisterium, which many people see as a reference to the Catholic Church's body of teachings of the same name. The anti-religious message was reportedly toned down compared to the book.
Bill Donohue of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights had charged that the books and movie sold “atheism for kids.”
He told the Evening Standard that he was “delighted that the boycott worked.”
"I knew if we could hurt the box office receipts here, it might put the brakes on the next movie,” he added.
Donohue said he protested the movie because of its “deceitful attempt to introduce Christian children to the wonders of atheism in a backdoor fashion at Christmas time.”
“Everyone agrees the film version was not anti-Catholic, but that hardly resolves the issue. The fact is that each volume in the trilogy becomes increasingly anti-Catholic,” he continued.
Pullman, the author of the book on which the Golden Compass was based, said that the likelihood of the film trilogy being completed is decreasing.
He said that Catholics’ efforts against the film “must have played a part” in the trilogy being shelved, the Telegraph reports.
Pullman has denied his series is anti-Catholic, claiming it is a warning about what religion can do “when it gets its hands on the levers of power.”
According to CinemaBlend.com, the first book of the His Dark Materials trilogy is the most mild “by far” and the movie had most of its anti-religion references stripped.
“That kind of sanitization would have been impossible when adapting later books,” the movie website continued, noting that the series “quite literally” becomes a story about homosexual angels trying to kill God.
The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Office for Film & Broadcasting had initially published a positive review of the movie, which was later pulled.
Archbishop of Denver Charles J. Chaput had said the film had an “aggressively anti-religious, anti-Christian undercurrent” and an “absence of joy or any real laughter.” He criticized the promotion of “this cold, angry, anti-religious fable” as holiday fare and invited Catholics to voice their concerns to New Line Cinema.
Bishop of LaCrosse, Wisconsin Jerome Listecki sent a letter about the film to his priests, urging them to warn parents about the books’ attacks on the Christian faith.
"Instead of using fantasy to lead people to truth and to God, this trilogy tries to lead them away from God," he said.
Maybe there is no planned sequel because the Golden Compass sucked???
My only recollection about this film is that the Demons were good. That’s all I needed to know I didn’t want to see it. The sequels can be made. Whether or not anyone would go see them is likely the holdup.
It's a business. You want to appeal to a broad audience, and they failed. And what is their reaction? Let's bash the Catholic Church all over again!! Let's get some last licks in!!
Thank you Catholic Church
Oh Sam, I am so disappointed. Always pegged you as a conservative and one who uses common sense. I’m crushed...
Why bother with market economics when a gratuitous, anti-Catholic slam will do?
You mean an organization which preaches the existence of God actually opposed an atheist propaganda ploy?
Imagine that?
The nerve!!!
The marketplace speaks!
yeah, blame the church, for a bad film.
Dang, I’d rather hear Sam read the phone book than most other actors do Shakespere... and now he comes out with this drivel.
I guess we’re just left with Tom Selleck for our westerns.
Uh, like Islam for instance?
Hey don’t give the Catholics all the credit. Some of us Protestants were on board with boycotting this movie. :-)
Exactly. Hollywood has never had any scruples when it comes to money, and least of all do they care what any Christian (as opposed to, say, Muslim) church thinks of it—all this since the end of the Production Code, at any rate. Before that, the opinion of the church did matter to a great extent.
Imagine that. Catholics not wanting to see a movie that is anti-Catholic!
Sorry Sam, if we don’t buy in to your anti-Christian movies.
Yeah, I know there was a huge campaign against the movie. But damn, blaming the Catholic Church for a piss poor movie?
I’ll bet Elliot has faith in Al Gore.
I used to like Sam Elliot too...
The visual graphics and special effects were nice, but that was about all it had going for it.
He's long gone from his best role ever as Sam Damon in "Once An Eagle". ABC needs to release that miniseries on DVD.
You had the best mustache in Tombstone
You added a wacky dash of humor to The Big Lebowski
You've been a reliable piece of scenery in many other Westerns
Stick to that and shut-up about politics!
He’s sooooo brave and elequent and the Catholic Church is sooooo eviiiiiil by stating what was very obvious in the books.
Let’s see this actor make an anti-Muslim film and see how that turns out.
Don’t know about the Smokey Bear thing, but it was a pretty bad movie.
I think the big ol’ mustache look works, but the early 80’s look (The Sacketts) was a bit too much.
Ah well, I guess it shouldn’t be that much of a surprise.
Of course that had nothing to do with the decision, right Sam?
Yeah I’m disappointed too. I’ve always enjoyed his movies.
Then we could say, "Homosexual opposition is to blame for not making Golden Compass sequels.
Never mind that economically, it did not make sense to make another movie. Blame it on the gays.
It is also the case that a lot of Hollywood is Jewish. Repeat the above exercise with 'gay' replaced by 'Jewish'.
Real nice, huh? And the left would do it in a heartbeat if they thought they could get away with it.
That having been said, The Golden Compass sucked.
A shame, too, because I always enjoyed Elliot as a western actor.
Maybe Sam Elliot wants to blame God, but instead goes after the Catholic Church. Perhaps this blasphemous person has gotten a glimpse of his afterlife.
No sequel to a movie that wants to “Kill God in the minds of Children”?
LOL
I liked Once an Eagle but I also liked The Sacketts and Shadow Riders.
I saw this movie on opening weekend, with about 10 other people in the whole theater. I was willing to let go of the anti-Catholic overtones because I really enjoy the steampunk or alternative history/universe genre. But this movie sucked. It was a bore and tedious. It is really hard to cheer for the “heroine” Lyra when she is a spolied brat who really was in need of a good spanking. The Magisterium was the worst villanous organization I ever seen. They were incompetent and shallow. I was thinking how is this organization suppose to conquer other universes when it cannot even get its act together in its own world.
No wonder it did so well in the European market opposed to the US market.
If they are handing out credit, I will accept my small part with humility.
Loved him in Tombstone and Road House.
I'm crushed to hear this crap from Sam. He is my absolute favorite actor and that voice makes me melt like butter... *sigh*. Another fantasy blown.
I just want to add that Golden Compass, I forget the real name, was the ultimate Dues Ex Machina. Everytime Lyra got into some trouble she would just whip it out and her problems were solved.
I know, right?
...He said the movie did “incredible” at the box office but the Catholic Church “lambasted” the filmmakers and “scared off” New Line Cinema executives.
The rule of thumb is that a film has to gross three times its production costs to break even once you pay for advertising, prints, distribution and the theater owners' cut. Three times $180M is $540M, which is a lot more than $380M. It was "incredible" at the box office in the sense of an incredible money losing stinkburger.
Most definitely. And that's saying something because The Big Lebowski is a THOROUGHLY wacky movie. It's one of the few movies that I'll watch in it's entirety several times a year.
this sounds to me like the plot of the next best-selling Dan Brown book...maybe Sam is angling for a role in that one when it is made into a movie...
Didn’t see Tombstone but Roadhouse was hard to take. You like characters and they kill them. lol
How about blaming the fact that the movie sucked for the lack of sequels.
I can’t see the pics...
I keep waiting to see the big-screen adaptation of The Satanic Verses, but it looks like it will never be made. Fancy that...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.