And yet you say it makes no sense to label these theories as "left wing." To me it makes perfect sense to label socialist sounding theories as left wing.
Sigh . . . not this again!
The whole point is that Left and Right often say the very same things, even as they consistently oppose one another. And that I don't accept the "totalitarian to anarchism" political spectrum so many conservatives promote. In Europe the Right is quite statist and collectivist, but it's still Right.