Skip to comments.Legitimating Bigotry
Posted on 05/11/2010 5:33:57 AM PDT by SJackson
Richard Goldstone, author of the notorious Goldstone report, did not become a South African judge in the post-Apartheid Mandela Era, as The New York Times and other media have erroneously reported. He accepted a judgeship during the worst days of Apartheid and helped legitimate one of the most racist regimes in the world by granting the imprimatur of the rule of law to some of the most undemocratic and discriminatory decrees.
Goldstone wasquite literallya hanging judge. He imposed and affirmed death sentences for more than two dozen blacks under circumstances where whites would almost certainly have escaped the noose. And he affirmed sentences of physical tortureeuphemistically called flogging for other blacks. He also enforced miscegenation and other racist laws with nary a word of criticism or dissent. He was an important part of the machinery of death, torture and racial subjugation that characterized Apartheid South Africa. His robe and gavel lent an air of legitimacy to an entirely illegitimate and barbaric regime.
It is no surprise that Goldstone kept this part of his life secret from academic colleagues, friends and the general public. I recall him at the lunch and dinner tables in Cambridge describing himself as a heroic part of the struggle against Apartheid. Now it turns out he was the ugly face of Apartheid, covering its sins and crimes with a judicial robe. How differently we would have looked at him if we knew that he had climbed the judicial ladder on whipped backs and hanged bodies.
Now that his dirty secret has been exposed to the world, he has invoked the defense raised by German judges at Nuremberg: I was just following the law. This cowardly defense was rejected at Nuremberg and by the international law that Goldstone claimed to be applying against Israel in the Goldstone report. It should be resoundingly rejected by the court of public opinion. Goldstones friend and former judicial colleague, Arthur Chaskalson, has rushed to the defense of his fellow South African judge, saying that it was better to have an honest judge on the bench than another kind. Putting aside the issue of whether Goldstone was an honest judgehis Goldstone Report strongly suggests he is another kindthe German judges offered precisely that argument at Nuremberg. I did it to help the Jews. In the film Judgment at Nuremberg, based on a real case, the judge argued that by unjustly sentencing one Jew to death, others might be helped. He also said he had no choice but to apply unjust laws. He was convicted. Goldstone may have persuaded himself and other judges who served the Apartheid regime that by hanging and torturing some blacks, they would be helping other blacks, but the only ones that were helped were the racists who ran the Apartheid regime and Goldstone himself, who used his Apartheid judgeship as a stepping stone and career booster.
It is interesting that Goldstone made a similar argument to friends as to why he accepted the chairmanship of the investigative commission offered to him by the United Nations Human Rights Council. He acknowledged that the Council was biased against Israel. Indeed, it treats Israel much the way Apartheid courts used to treat Black Africans: Just as there was special justice (really injustice) for blacks, so too there is special justice (really injustice) for Israel. Goldstone claims he took the job to help Israel, just as he took his previous job to help blacks. In both cases he cynically hurt those he said he wanted to help while helping only himself. In both cases he was selected to legitimate bigotry. In both cases, better people than him refused to lend their credibility to an illegitimate enterprise. But Goldstone accepted, because it was good for his career.
Goldstone is an ambitious opportunist who lacks the courage of his convictions if he ever had any. He has always put personal advancement over principle. He is a master of rationalization and self justification. This time he has run out of excuses. Hes been exposed as a poseur who will sell his integrity for a careerist opportunity. Fortunately he now has little integrity left to sell.
If youd like to be on or off, please FR mail me.
This guy is one of the worst -—— just ask the Goldman’s family in LA about how he took care of OJ ...
for a fee, of course.
I wouldn’t listen to a word he said about anything ....
Are you talking about Goldman, or Horowitz? Either way, could you give us a few insights? Thanks.
If the NYT ( aka Ministry of Truth) says Mr. Goldstone was an honest and fair judge who came to the bench AFTER apartheid ended, and that he has now ALWAYS been an honest and fair judge who came to power AFTER apartheid ended; then as far as I am concerned Mr. Goldstone was an honest and fair judge who came to the bench AFTER apartheid ended, and he has now ALWAYS been an honest and fair judge who came to power after apartheid ended.
...and I LOVE Big Brother and I SURE don’t want to go spend any more time in the basement of the Ministry of Love.
Whoops, sorry. Meant to say Dershowitz.
Your perogative. Why bother to read it?
I saw him when he was heading an "official" panel that was touring the US and Canada. The panel mandated "conditional independence" for an Albanian muslim-occupied Kosovo. Of course, later the panel's mandate was achieved--the bogus "Kosovo independence" was granted, even though it is not recognized by most of the world's countries.
Goldstone's Serbophobe panel included Harvard Law School's Martha Minow, Barack Hussein obama's mentor at Harvard law School, who "predicted" way back that obama would become President (maybe with the help of her muslim friends?). Minow replaced Elena Kagan as Harvard Law School dean, after Kagan joined the obama administration. Harvard Kennedy School's Michael Ignatieff was also on the panel--he is now leader of the opposition in Canada.
Goldstone, a Jew, is against Israel as well as Serbia. Ignatieff, a Russian Orthodox Christian (perhaps a nominal one), is a vicious Serbophobe who works hard to destroy his Orthodox brothers and sisters--he may end up leading Canada. The Serbophobe Minow and her friend and colleague Kagan are busy destroying America. All have muslim and New World Order connections. Go figure!
Alan hears the crocodile’s jaws snapping. It’s not going to eat him last after all.
Dershowitz is right in his criticism of the Goldstone Report. Israel did the right thing in Gaza.
But I am sickened by Dershowitz’s defence of black criminals in apartheid South Africa, who were fully deserving of being executed. That is like saying that black murderers who were legally executed in Southern States before 1964, should not have been executed, because those states had segregationist policies.
Why is Dershowitz not talking about the out-of-control violent crime in South Africa, which has caused the deaths of hundreds of thousands of white and black South Africans since 1994? One of the most endangered groups, are the white farmers of South Africa, who are being targeted for murder, and 3,000 have been killed.
Judge Goldstone should be congratulated for maintaining law and order in white-ruled South Africa, where violent crime rates were very low. But Goldstone should be denounced for preventing Israel from enforcing law and order, meant to safeguard the lives of Israeli citizens.
My. What a surprise. Goldstone is really an immoral judicial whore. Who would have guessed?