Being indifferent to the safety and security of the Israeli people does not a “good Jew” make.
That's not what I said.
Some American jews think that Zionism reduces the safety and security of the Israeli people.
Liberal American jews agree with Helen Thomas, and they don't like conservatives who are sympathetic to the National interests of Israel.
It's surprising that so many people are so ignorant of this distinction, and always seem to be mystified by the apparent contradictions in American Jews' political leanings.
It's not contradictory at all. Liberal American Jews don't think like we do.