Replies

I know quite a bit about the Warsaw Ghetto because I have family who survived that Ghetto although. It is true that the Jewish council did cooperate. Most members of the council thought they were helping to make an unthinkable situation only bad. I’m sure a few were thinking about how to save their families. While they were unable to help in the long run, I don’t think they did any harm that wouldn’t have been done. If I was being as selective in the facts I told to recreate history as you, I would say that the council gave time for the planning of the Uprising. The truth though is that local factories were upset about the prospect of losing free slave labor and they slowed down the process of evacuations. The funny thing about history is you could look at it and make almost any conclusion you want by only looking at certain facts. That doesn’t make your conclusion true.

I don’t think I’m going to change your opinion on the Jews involvement in the Holocaust, but I would ask that you understand it comes across as hateful even though I’m sure that’s not your intention.

Non sequitur.

One more time, as it applies in 2011.

What I am trying to understand is why SOME — not all — Jews would actively support by words, deeds, and money either individuals or organizations that are committed to their destruction or to the destruction of their country. This applies to American Jews and Israeli Jews.

You have a sitting American president and an administration that are actively as antisemitic as I have ever seen — whether it applies to the United States or towards Israel. That is what I cannot fathom. I want you to explain this to me because all I have done is point out that such Jews exist. Do you deny they exist?

Explain to me why a rational person would support individuals or organizations committed to their destruction or the destruction of their country?