Posted on 09/13/2011 10:04:41 AM PDT by WesternCulture
An Italian politician was convicted by a Swedish court on Tuesday for assaulting his son while on holiday in Stockholm in a case that has sparked heated debate in both Italy and Sweden.
In finding Giovanni Colasante, 46, a local politician from Canosa di Puglia in southern Italy, guilty of assault, the court fined him 6,600 kronor ($990).
Colasante was arrested on August 23rd as he and his family were about to enter a Stockholm eatery in the city's historic Gamla Stan (Old Town) district.
They were in the Swedish capital on vacation as part of a cruise that was to take them to several Nordic countries.
But when Colasante's 12-year-old son refused to go into the restaurant, the boy's father reacted and, according to witnesses, attacked the young lad.
“He lifted his son up by the hair,” eye witness Deniz Cinkitas told the Aftonbladet newspaper following the incident.
Other guests at the restaurant called police and Colasante was placed under arrest for breaking Sweden's laws outlawing corporal punishment, putting a dent in the remainder of the family's travel plans.
While no one denies that a disagreement took place, exactly how Colasante may have treated his son remains a matter of interpretation.
According to the district court's ruling, four witnesses testified to seeing Colasante pull his son's hair before rushing over to prevent any further violence.
However, testimony regarding the blows that Colasante allegedly dealt out was less certain. As a result, the Italian politician was convicted of abuse based solely on having pulled his son's hair.
Despite the fact that an adult was seen to have committed violence against a child, the court deemed the assault to be minor as Colasante only caused his son pain for a few seconds.
In deciding on Colasante's punishment, the court took into account that he has been held by police since his arrest.
The fact that Colasante was held against his will and saddled with travel restrictions is unusual for minor offences, but occurred in this case because the court wanted to make sure that he didn't leave the country.
The Italian embassy in Stockholm refused to comment on the verdict, but confirmed embassy official had been in contact with Colasante.
“We have just gotten word of this sentence, and he will discuss with his lawyer what he will do next,” Caterina Gioiella, embassy First Secretary told The Local.
Colasante's case has garnered a great deal of attention in the media in Italy, which is among the 11 EU countries without a law forbidding corporal punishment.
Sweden was the first to introduce a formal ban on corporal punishment back in 1979 and a slew of countries have since followed suit. The Swedish ban has faced scrutiny and been roundly criticised in some areas of the Italian media.
Mali Nilsson, responsible for the international work on corporal punishment at Save the Children Sweden, has followed the debate in Italy.
She has concluded that the discussion has been based on an incorrect view of Swedish legislation.
"It is thought that the law is intended to criminalise parents and that neighbours should report one another. But we know that the law has not led to more parents losing their children. Nor was that the intention; the purpose is preventative - to protect children," she said.
Of the EU's 27 member states, 16 have a law against corporal punishment. In Italy it is expressly forbidden in schools, but not in the home.
Save the Children Italy lobbies for a change in the law, but has noted that Colasante's case has stirred such strong emotions in the country that a planned campaign on the issue could be put on ice, Mali Nilsson explained.
"They may have to wait with their campaign. But my colleagues also say that the case has at least prompted a debate, and that could be something," she said.
As a child grows, reason can take a much larger place.
As a child grows, reason can take a much larger place.
Perhaps you are.
My first thought was, Wow, that must be a tall strong father or a short skinny kid.
I think some of those Sisters of Mercy were Sicilians,
And, taught them everything they know:it seems from some of the punishments they coule mede out:)
We had/have a large community of Italian immigrants in New Orleans, as well as Irish and German. The Italians gravitated toward the French Quarter/Market where they would sell their produce and start restaurants and businesses. (We still have mafa here) And,we still have a store in the FQ that is straight out of the early 1900’s and makes the best muffalatas(sp) in the city - Central Grocery is a must visit when in NOLA.
Oh, I know the French Quarter very well! I used to be taken there every year on my birthday but after Katrina we sort of faded it out.
Do you know that Tennessee Williams always wrote about the Sicilians of New Orleans and Louisiana? His play “The Rose Tattoo” is about a Sicilian seamstress and “Orpheus Descending” recounts the terrible lynching of the Italian community in New Orleans in the late 19th century. I think Williams turned it into a fire rather than a lynching. Chilling.
But, as always, the Sicilians landed on their feet and flourished in America.
I’ve been to the Central Grocery. One year we bought muffalettas (I know I’m butchering the spelling!) and took them out to the plantation homes and ate them while gazing at the Mississippi.
To begin with; No people are in need of their government telling them what to do, how to live their lives and how to raise their families.
Secondly; as a Swede, I happen to disagree with the idea of lifting a boy in his hair.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.