[DiogenesLamp]

Good work, though, on sharing these two cases that explicitly state that the U.S.-born children of foreigners are “natural born citizens.” Particularly Diaz-Salazar, since it’s a federal Court of Appeals decision.

It IS a good job! Discovering that it was the decision of a Carter appointee PROVES it cannot be correct! Ergo, the opposite is assured to be true.

[sometime lurker]

See my post 18. In addition to the Carter appointee, the other judges in the cases were appointed by Presidents Reagan, Eisenhower, and Nixon.

[Ha Ha Thats Very Logical]

Discovering that it was the decision of a Carter appointee PROVES it cannot be correct!

I've seldom seen such a clear-cut example of the ad hominem fallacy. Readers take note: this is what the term really refers to, not just insults.