No flaw. You based your argument on the fact that many ‘conservatives’ got on board the MR bus. He is provably no conservative. I countered that many ‘scientists’ got on board the GW bus and there’s no global warming scientifically provable.
The inference is that a ‘group’ of educated idiots relied on the ‘group’ rather than demonstrated facts to form their conclusions.
Just like we see on this thread. A group of so called ‘conservatives’ got on MR’s bus because other so called ‘conservatives’ did. They are in fear of Obama and in fear of being outside the ‘cool kids’ group. This is the behavior of sheep, not thinking men and women. AKA Herd mentality.
No error in my logic.
The flaw lies in the fact that your analogy implies the condemnation of a consensus purely because it is a consensus.