I’m sure a comparison could be made, but it’s probably pretty tortured.
The new high performance 9mm bullets have a good record compared to the old ball ammo.
And frontal area of the bullet makes a difference too, that’s my my preferred revolver round is a .44 Special SWC.
I own a Charter Arms Bulldog Pug in .44spl and it seems to me it should come off pretty well compared to a .45acp. Some of the smaller 1911 variants have short barrels and similar capacity to the pug.