[uncbob]

The people that wrote the bill and promoted it said it was not a tax... the bill says it is not a tax... roberts rewrote that bill making it a tax. It does not matter what you post. roberts violated his oath of office and killed Constitutional rule.

And Roberts said the GOP Members in congress who said that it was in reality a tax were RIGHT ( a rose by any other name is a rose )and the democrats who wrote the bill and said it wasn't LIED

And he also said that the democrat argument that it was legal under the Commerce provisions were WRONG

In other words the GOP was right and the democrats were liars

And as others have pointed out being a tax makes many facets of the Bill unconstitutional but since nobody has been affected yet they can't rule on that until the aggrieved go to court but will if it doesn't get repealed before then

[LibLieSlayer]

None of that matters. Kennedy was set to strike the entire law... roberts violated his oath of office and rewrote the law to allow it to stand... and he legislated from the bench in violation of the Constitution... which was nullified yesterday by this decision. No spin can remove the fact that the rule of law and the US Constitution no longer supply any protections or guide any of our laws... this decision put us firmly into a post Constitutional era.

LLS