I respect what you say, but I differ with your opinion for reasons already listed.
Perry wasn't my first choice, I ranked him as third in my early preferences, and had Palin run I would have ranked him fourth. I do think he would have been a candidate we could have all gotten behind had he won.
I was a bit too hard on him early; when he came out of his stupor at the end I really came to appreciate his abilities, it was simply too late then and he got behind Newt.