Skip to comments.Harry Reid: Regulations have nothing to do with killing jobs
Posted on 11/15/2012 6:09:04 PM PST by SeekAndFind
Sen. Harry Reid, in a floor speech Tuesday:
Republicans "have yet to produce a single shred of evidence that the regulations they hate so much do the broad economic harms they claim. That's because there is none," said Reid, the Senate majority leader from Nevada.
In a Senate speech, Reid said the Bureau of Labor Statistics has concluded "only a tiny fraction of layoffs have anything at all to do with tighter regulation."
"Last year, only three-tenths of 1 percent of people who lost their jobs were let go principally because of government regulation or intervention," Reid said. "On the other hand, a quarter of them were laid off because of lack of business.
The Heritage Foundation’s James Gattuso explains the statistic:
The numbers come from the Labor Departments Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), which, in cooperation from state authorities, tracks mass layoffs, defined as layoffs of 50 or more workers for 31 days or more. In each case in which such a mass layoff is identified, state authorities interview the employers involved, asking them (among other things) the reason for the layoffs. For the third quarter, BLS reported that 0.3 percent of respondents listed governmental regulations/intervention as the reason…
It appears to be a simple process, but its actually quite tricky. The first problem is that economic hardship does not come with labels. Employers know if their costs are rising but not necessarily whether it is due to new burdens imposed on their suppliers or other factors. They may know that they didnt get the capital they needed but not if it was because investors had better opportunities or because of government financial rules. They will know if demand has slumped, but its not so clear whether it was because their product is valued less by the marketplace or because government rules choked off demand from customers. The actual causes are likely to be mixed.
But even if government interviewers could identify with precision the reasons for mass layoffs, that would tell us little about why unemployment is so high. Mass layoffs are only part of the job loss picturejob losses dont always come 50 or more at a time. Most small businesses dont even have 50 employees.
But where Reid and others really miss the mark, however, is in assuming that job losses are the problem, rather than a lack of job creation. As argued by my colleague James Sherk, layoffs spiked early in the recession but then they fell sharply. Since late 2009, gross job losses in the economy have actually been below their pre-recession levels. In fact, in 2010 there were fewer gross job losses than any time since the government began tracking these figures in 1992. Unemployment remains high because the economy has not been creating jobs. Last September, for instance, employers hired only 4.2 million new workersa million fewer monthly new hires than before the recession.
Let’s lay aside the fact that it is job creation that’s most of our problem and that all the layoffs we’ve been hearing about lately seem to be Obamacare regulation-related.
Sen. Harry Reid, meet the people you think don’t exist. A boutique, local, organic, artisan maker of cured meats is closing in Denver thanks to a USDA regulation that would require him to taint his all-natural, Old World methods for making his product in order to comply:
“In August, the USDA imposed additional requirements on Il Mondo Vecchios production methods. After two months of sharing information and collaboration back and forth between Il Mondo Vecchio and the USDA as well as various attempts to modify the production methods,” the owners announced, “Il Mondo Vecchio has determined that the impact of the regulatory requirements on dry cured sausage products was detrimental to the quality of the product and therefore, Mark and Gennaro are forced to close the[ir] doors.”
This conflict between modern regulations and traditional methods is something DeNittis thought for a time he could navigate.
“We adhere to Old World techniques of natural process while following New World regulations, Il Mondo Vecchios website states.
When it comes to Old World methods, I think it would be hard to find a better example of a traditional, conscientious, sustainable, and local producer than Il Mondo Vecchio.
The product has, of course, never sickened anyone or faced any complaint, and Denver foodies will count it a loss to their community. This is, literally, the war on bacon.
And, one man’s dream, his livelihood, his community, and his employees are poorer for it. But by all means, keep piling them on, Harry.
This guy belongs in a straightjacket in a rubber room.
Gadianton Harry at it again.
And oxygen has nothing to do with breathing. Thank you "Hair Brained Harry."
Regulations have lots to do with killing American jobs.
So frankly, so does greed.
We Mr. Reid will do something about the greedballs.
You however are entirely now on the hook, for getting rid of regulations and rules, which stand in the way.
FUHR you simpleton low life scum!
A lifetime public leech lecturing businesses? Bwhahaha.
Republicans “have yet to produce a single shred of evidence that the regulations they hate so much do the broad economic harms they claim. That’s because there is none,” said Reid
Attention, Attention! Someone call Harry Reid, the village wants their idiot back! Harry has no clue and continues to carry water for Obama....the dumb leading the dumber!
Biden is “hair” brained.
Dingy Harry is the old fashioned “hare” brained type.
Refutation by Dear Leader:
“So if somebody wants to build a coal-powered plant, they can. It’s just that it will bankrupt them because theyre going to be charged a huge sum for all that greenhouse gas that’s being emitted.”
- Do you really need to know who said this?
That Reid is mentally challenged is a given. That he thinks he’s not is the problem.
This. Guy. Idiot.
Oh really Harry,
Scroll down to ADA and AIDS.. There you will find what your Regs can do to a small business, that I am very aware of..
This shitty little insect needs to have his head pinched off,
Harry Reid is going to die of septicemia eating his own excrement in such large piles.
Deck chair coordinator on the Titanic...look up clueless moron idiot in the dictionary there is a picture of Reid....
AND I GOT A BRIDGE I CAN SELL YA HARRY YOU FRIGGIN MORON! Why he is still in the Senate is amazing. STUPID PEOPLE keep these idiots in office!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Harry does such a good imitation of pond scum.
You can get rid of all regulations and we still can’t compete with communist china’s $2/day wages. Restore the import tariffs.
The sad part is he really believes this.
Harry Reid’s mob connections have nothing to do with his corrupt behavior in the Senate. /s
The man is an imbecile
The personification of Stuck on Stupid
Wow. Shame on Nevada.
As a life-long public sector leech, his only real world experience with regulations is that those are the things he gets pay-offs for, from the people who are paying him off to look the other way.
That makes me smile.
Let's take a business
Let's add regulation. Restrictions, licenses, fees, paperwork.
Let's increase the minimum wage.
Let's increase mandated benefits (health care, unemployment, etc.)
Let's increase the cost of energy through misguided energy policy
Let's increase taxes. All taxes. Income taxes, corporate taxes, capital gains taxes, energy taxes, tolls, fees, etc.
Let's institute lawsuits for descrimation, environmental violations, jobsite safety, yada yada yada.
Let's do everything we can to strengthen union power
Let's denegrate capital formation and investment.
Let's do all these things and then cross our fingers for job creation.
Welcome to Obamanomics.
Just ask me, Harry . . . POS . . . . how can these people sleep at night???
According to the BLS (Bureau of Lying Statistics), the cheap political whore of the administration....yah, I believe everything they say.
I can think of one right off the bat that dirty Harry shamelessly rammed through Congress in the middle of the night and on weekends, ignoring public outrage: OBAMACARE
WHY is that pusillanimous pustule still sucking oxygen?
Reid,like Obama and Pelosi, hasn’t so much as run a hot dog stand and has no clue what it is like to run a business or make a payroll. They are clueless about how much time and money is wasted on permits, approvals and mindless government paperwork. Many businesses need to have full time government compliance specialists that are just an overhead cost and don’t add a dime to the bottom line. When I worked in the private sector, I was a government affairs liaison for a national corporation and my sole job was to get the permits and government approvals needed to develop new projects.
Of course not Harry, we just lay people off because we want to do less business and make less money.
Sometimes there’s just not enough Geritol.
what vile, evil, empty, corrupt, and angry man he is.
Not only that, I believe he is mentally ill.
Along with Pelosi and Obama. And we think the Republican party leadership has problems?
What a sad reflection of our country.
of course he is bat s%#t crazy..
But he has a point.
Have they made the case that they do?
Parade a bunch of small business owners in front of them. Ask them how much time and money they spend on compliance issues vs their actual business. Hand Reid a copy of economist Hernando de Soto’s book, “The Bell Jar” in which he looks at how the regulatory state in South America is holding back economic growth there.
I wish Reid would suffer Herod’s fate.
That this cretin got to lead the Senate shows how far this country has fallen.
sounds like a good idea. but the point of my post is that Reid is right. They have not done what you suggest.
One thing I just found out today at work is a nice little nugget tucked in the Dodd-Frank bill. They have classified gold, tungsten, and titanium as conflict metals. All our suppliers now have to certify that none of these metals are “conflict” metals. It is a huge compliance issue for us with all the wiring and pcbas
No they don't tina. Cheaters do. Do a little bit of research on how he got re-elected. Obama learned from Reid.
Communist Enablers File.
Our senate Moron-in-Chief heard from.