If you can find something similar for the 3 great 8+ quakes for New Madrid, MO, 1811-12 that will give you some idea. There also there were many lesser quakes.
Something a lot of people don't realize is that a young Abraham Lincoln lived just 250 miles from the quakes' epicenters and Jefferson Davis had lived less than 150 miles away, but his family had moved to Louisiana just a few months earlier. What would history be like if one, or both, of those young children (Lincoln was 2 and Davis was 3 at the time) had been killed in the quake?