[metmom]

A Vatican spokesman said the decision "took us by surprise".

That's odd. If his health is that poor, you'd think someone would have noticed.

You'd hope that people would not be so oblivious.

[Elsie]

So much for the healiung power of Jesus...

[PeevedPatriot]

If his health is that poor, you'd think someone would have noticed.You'd hope that people would not be so oblivious.

The man began using a moving platform last year to reduce his walking distance. It's well known that Benedict had at least one stroke prior to his election. Ever notice his crooked smile? There are other signs of his having had a stroke too.

The fact that a spokesman is surprised doesn't mean he's oblivious to Benedict's health. It just means he's surprised.

I appreciate Pope Benedict's service to the Church. He could have declined and spent the best of his last remaining years of health with his brother. And doing what he loved--study. But he had the obedience to accept what was asked of him. Now he has the humility to admit his physical limitations. May God grant that I be as faithful as he has been!

[EDINVA]

The decision to resign took the spokesman by surprise, not Benedict’s failing health, Or were you trying to be cute?

[Cronos]

If your health (physical or mental) were poor, would you think someone would have noticed. or would it be something personal?

Health is pretty personal, right? After all you won't even talk of your beliefs as it is personal, right? So health too..