Skip to comments.The Last Communist City A visit to the dystopian Havana that tourists never see
Posted on 05/13/2014 3:55:45 PM PDT by Hojczyk
I had to lie to get into the country. Customs and immigration officials at Havanas tiny, dreary José Martí International Airport would have evicted me had they known I was a journalist.
Outside its small tourist sector, the rest of the city looks as though it suffered a catastrophe on the scale of Hurricane Katrina or the Indonesian tsunami. Roofs have collapsed. Walls are splitting apart. Window glass is missing. Paint has long vanished.
Housing is free, too, but so what? Americans can get houses in abandoned parts of Detroit for only $500which makes them practically freebut no one wants to live in a crumbling house in a gone-to-the-weeds neighborhood. I saw adequate housing in the Cuban countryside, but almost everyone in Havana lives in a Detroit-style wreck, with caved-in roofs, peeling paint, and doors hanging on their hinges at odd angles.
Supposedly, the maids get about $1 per day for each room. If they clean an average of 30 rooms a day and work five days a week, theyll bring in $600 a month30 times what everyone else gets. All animals are equal, George Orwell wrote in Animal Farm, his allegory of Stalinism, but some animals are more equal than others. Only in the funhouse of a Communist country is the cleaning lady rich compared with the lawyer. Yet elite Cubans are impoverished compared with the middle class and even the poor outside Cuba.
(Excerpt) Read more at city-journal.org ...
In Stalinist Russia conditions were much the same.
But they didn’t have old American cars to work on.
Just look at Detroit. That is what the future has in store for you!
The powers to be want to turn the US into a third world wasteland, solely for exploiting the intrinsic wealth of the land, like colonial times of old.
We've come full circle; now the colonial oligarchs have come home to roost, and their ambitions include the US, Mexico, and Canada.
Our federal government has less legitimacy than Venezuela or Zimbabwe for that matter.
That's what happens when you sell your soul and sell your country out to the highest bidder. In the end, all of those worthless dollars will not save you from a certain, horrible death.
Not that much better In Putin’s dump
The heretic must be destroyed. Cuba is a workers paradise with free stuff for everyone.
“Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, authors of The Communist Manifesto, would be appalled by the misery endured by Cubas ordinary citizens and shocked by the relatively luxurious lifestyles of those who keep the poor down by force”
Bull. Marx and Engels would have been pretty satisfied with the consequences of marxism as long as they were among the elites whose rules didnt apply to them.
He overstates the physical decay of the city — it’s not that bad, and that photo is highly selective — but not the condition of its citizens. And the elites do live in luxury, and send their families to hospitals in Europe when they get sick. On top of which it’s highly racist — heavily black population and almost none in the government. Oh, and that not-allowed-to-leave thing.
Another thought — he’s absolutely right that Cuba had a thriving middle class and thriving economy in the 50’s. But the populace absolutely wanted to get rid of Batista, because corruption had invaded everyday life and because civil freedoms had been suspended, and Castro had huge popular support, because he told them what they wanted to hear — that there would be freedom of the press, honest elections and transparency of government. A million people turned out to cheer him the night he marched in Havana after the war, in a genuine outpouring of support and excitement. But alas, there was just one catch: he was lying the whole time. The secret communist government began meeting within the first week, and the murders of the honest rebels began around the same time.
Not necessarily doubting you but I'd like to see the evidence for this. Where are you getting this?
A million people turned out to cheer him the night he marched in Havana after the war...
A million people according to who? Communist sources or trustworthy sources?
But haven’t Michael Moore and Sen. Tom Harkin both sung Cuba’s praises? Didn’t Moore say the Cuban health care is superior to ours and Harkin claimed Cuba’s life expectancy is greater than in the US. Useful idiots.
Quickly coming to America, courtesy of Obama and his liberal nut friends! Guaranteed if Hillary is elected President!
Hard to point to one source as I’ve done years of research on this and spent much time in Cuba, had many conversations with Cubans young and old there and in Miami (where they don’t have to lower their voices and turn the music up louder when they are talking to you.) The tragedy isn’t that he bulldozed an unwilling populace, the tragedy is that they gave their lives for him willingly. Endless footage of people cheering and weeping with joy and embracing the revolutionaries as they came down out of the hills (where they kept themselves safe while others risked their lives). Tad Szulc’s biography is a good source. Even better is Georgie Geyer’s Guerilla Prince because she was a conservative and saw the betrayal with a clear eye, and spent time with Fidel himself without being fooled for a second the way so many other journalists were. The million people or at any rate an enormous crowd is something you can see on archival film — it’s staggering — I’ve stood in the square that the crowd filled, and it could hold an entire city. And not only that — a few white doves flew from seemingly nowhere and landing on Fidel’s shoulders while he was addressing the crowd. One of them stayed there for an hour. A magnificent piece of theater. It took almost a year before people started to catch onto the truth.
The powers that be....
No wonder the Cuban people make the perilous and dangerous journey across the Florida straits to try and live like a human being....
Totten is an excellent self-employed, independent, journalist/photographer. He has reported from Iraq, Afghanistan and, recently, from Thailand. He has a blog under his name where you can read past reports and donate for support.
Last Communist city? Pffffffft!!
He does great work. The times I’ve donated I’ve gotten a personal thanks from him.
I went to Cuba and stayed at the Havana Libre. I also traveled outside of the bubble many miles from Havana. The author nailed it.
Makes me sick when liberal politicians come back from their government controlled tour and brag on Cuba. Micheal Moore is an idiot. Party members and tourist go to good hospitals, everyone else is screwed.
A guy showed me his ration book; when his son turned 7 no more milk. All the Cubans I met were great people, all were very cynical of the government
There’s a reason why doctors get $20 a month but the police get $40-50.
Take care of the people who keep you in power.
But Cuba is a vision of the future of the United States as imagined by the current social architects of the Left: widespread equalization of income which is, in fact, equalization of poverty, a middle class destroyed by it, a rigid police state enforcing it, and an elite ruling class living off it. Freedom only for the nomenklatura at first; freedom for no one in the end. What is astounding to me is that despite the clear examples of Cuba and North Korea, they still can sell the lie.
Yes. Now I think it’s called Plaza Jose Marti. Not sure what it was called then — it wouldn’t have been named for a hero of the revolution! My most vivid sources were my interviews with old warriors in Miami who had fought with Fidel in the mountains during the war because they believed he was going to bring justice and democracy to the island, and then after the victory, when they said to him “Um, about those elections?” he had many of them arrested and imprisoned for years without trial. One of them, Mario Chanes De Armas — you can look him up — was in jail for 27 years, longer than Mandela, making him the longest-held political prisoner of modern times. He’s my main source for stories about how bad Batista was. Garden variety corrupt strongman. Even Eisenhower hated him, which is one of the reasons Fidel was able to win — Eisenhower pulled the plug on support. You can tell that I am little obsessed with this thing, even though it’s been almost twenty years since I did this research.
Ex Governor Charlie Christ is thinking about visiting Cuba. He is now saying that Americans should travel to Cuba. Another one of his flip flops...
A most interesting read for when you have a few extra minutes.
-—Take care of the people who keep you in power.-—
Sounds like Obama MO....
And, worth every penny!
Batista, a mixed race “mulato”, as it is Obama, was a populist who enjoyed the support of the Blacks and many in the working class. The revolution was supported by the students, the professionals, and many in the middle class. We repudiated the fact that Bastista gave a Coup d’état 90 days before a democratic election where he also was a candidate for the presidency.
Batista was in power in 1930’s after being overthrown president Gerardo Machado by a revolution that was followed by a military junta headed by then an army sergeant, Fulgencio Batista. Batista won the presidential election in 1940 and called for a new Constitution in which were represented delegates of all the parties, including the communists. It was a very advanced constitution.
In 1944 Batista delivered the presidency to the opposition and Ramon Grau San Martin, a professor of medicine, was elected in a landslide. Batista left the country to later come back and was elected senator in democratic elections.
In the ominous March 10, 1952, Batista took power by a military coup 90 days before the elections. He remained a de facto president till December 31, 1958, when he left the country in the middle of the night leaving the country in the hands of Fidel Castro, a gangster during his student time in the Habana University, and his communist comrades. Although there was corruption in his regime, nevertheless, Bastista left over $500 million in the Treasure in dollars and gold, and did not left internal or exterior debt. The Cuban peso was accepted internationally on par to the dollar.
The rise and fall of the Republic of Cuba is well documented. From being a country with the highest standard of living in Latin America, in spite of all the crisis and pains common at the birth of a new republic, Cuba became a giant prison island under the boot of a totalitarian Stalinist regime that brought to its knees a proud people who fought for more than 15 years a bloody war to gain its independence from Spain, and valiantly resisted the takeover of the country communist. Under the communists tyrants, more Cubans were assassinated by the regime and more patriots suffered long years of brutal jail imprisonment in proportion to its population than during the regimen of Stalin.
Mr. Totten article is one of the best written by a non Cuban in the quest for the truth behind the Cuban tragedy.
Top sources of information are Armando Valladares, Against All Hope: A Memoir of Life in Castro’s Gulag a vivid portrait of his 22 years imprisonment in the regime dungeons. Humberto Fontova, books and articles are also first class source for historians.
The English left-wing historian Hugh Thomas wrote one of the most comprehensive studies of the history of Cuba since its discovery by Columbus to the Batista government, “Cuba, The Pursuit of Freedom.” He wrote a follow up book in Spanish in 1982: “Contemporary History of Cuba, Batista to the Present Day.”
“In Cuba, communism has not brought fraternity, nor wealth, nor justice”... Categorically said English historian, Hugh Thomas.
Let us read Armando Valladares’ first hand depiction how well Communism works
Torture in Castro’s Cuba:
“I know the taste of the urine and the excrement of other men that practice does not leave marks; marks are left by beatings with steel rods and by bayonet thrusts. My head is still covered with scars and you can feel the cracks.
Armando Valladares, is a Cuban poet released (because of international pressure) from Castro’s political dungeons in 1982 after serving 22 years of a 30 year sentence for publicly opposing the Communist take over of the Cuban Revolution.
Valladares was liberated thanks to international pressure and the personal intervention of French president Francois Mitterant. Lagter, President Reagan made him U.S. Ambassador to the United Nation’s Commission on Human Rights. As Head of the U.S. Delegation, Valladares successfully brought Cuba before the Commission for its human rights violations and for the first time the Cuban regime was condemned after so many years of indifference towards the crimes committed by the communist regime. President Reagan would later confer on him the nations highest civil honor, the Presidential Citizens Medal. Valladares Memoirs, Against all Hope, was a best seller in the United States and around the world and has been translated to numerous languages.
Valladares vividly expressed how much it meant the international reaction to the Cuban political martyrdom: “During those years, with the purpose of forcing us to abandon our religious beliefs and to demoralize us, the Cuban Communist indoctrinators repeatedly used the statements made by some representatives of the American Christian churches. Every time a pamphlet was published in U.S., every time a clergyman would write an article in support of Castro’s dictatorship, a translation would be given to us, and that was far worse for the Christian political prisoners than the beatings or the hunger. Incomprehensible to us, while we waited for the embrace of solidarity from our brothers in Christ, those who were embraced were our tormentors.”
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.