Jewish Americans are rabidly ‘open borders’ immigration radicals, too stupid to look at how that policy would work in Israel.
It would do the same here, but they are too dumb to see it.
You are painting with much too broad of a brush. Most Jewish Americans here on FR are certainly NOT "rabidly 'open borders' immigration radicals."
Never mind how open borders would work in Israel. (BTW, it would be a disaster, as you implied).
The big question is how "open borders" is working in the United States. If I may say so as a Jewish American FReeper, it is a disaster here as well, and the situation is rapidly getting worse. These open borders illegal immigrants tend to be much more anti-Semitic and anti-Israel than the current American population, yet contribute disproportionally to crime and poverty, thus running up already insane government budget deficits and debt at federal, state, and local levels. They also compete for jobs with American citizens and lower wages.
No, we cannot tolerate open borders much longer. We can admit a limited number of immigrants, but they should be vetted carefully on a case-by-case basis so that they are likely to have the skills to support themselves. Illegal aliens have violated are laws, and should be politely escorted back to their country of origin.
BTW, I don't know if Eric Cantor is an "open borders" type but his fuzziness on the immigration issue was NOT what voters in the district wanted to hear, and justifiably so.