It is not hard to make sense of it. It is IMPOSSIBLE to make sense of it. So if this is what you think the Bible teaches then you are misinterpreting the teaching of the Bible.
Listen to me. Concentrate. You claim that every human ever born is given a binary choice - eternal bliss or eternal agony. And you think a significant fraction of humanity is going to freely choose eternal agony?
No.
I “claim” nothing. I am just trying to figure things out.