Replies

I think that helping others is a wonderful thing, but...

Well reasoned and written!

Realistically the chance that treatment in the US, compared to treatment there, can materially affect the survival chances of these two charitable, good, Americans is, at most, some small fraction of two individuals. The risk in bringing them here is a series of progressively smaller chances multiplied by a series of progressively larger victim pools. It isn't clear the former is greater than the latter. Primum Non Nocere!

Another risk with bringing them here is that people infected with Ebola may not think and act rationally. Disease barriers such as protective clothing and isolation rooms presume the patient will cooperate. That may, dangerously, not be true. Check out the story of the 'American' with Ebola who died in Nigeria en route back home linked within that post. Of course he might have acted that way just because he, as an African government bureaucrat, thought he was entitled. Like those with whom Obama is meeting this weekend.

Sending volunteers from the US, including volunteers from the CDC, to help provide care there avoids involuntary risk for the innocent here. CDC sends volunteer field teams into risks all the time.

You are so correct. yes, we have CDC labs with Ebola in them, but everything is controlled. The virus is in a vial, protected. the technician most likely in a full air conditioned hazmat suit works with the virus under a hood.
In this situation, you have a living breathing patient who can projectile vomit, have explosive diarrhea, and bleed all over the bed. It could affect him mentally, in which he acts irrationally. The virus will be all over the room, unlike a CDC lab.The risk of exposure is much greater. Also,the long incubation and death period has huge risks to it. It appears to me with the longer incubation period, and the increased time it takes a person to die, that the virus has already mutated. No virus wants to kill a host quickly. I remember when Ebola first hit, death was pretty fast. It was harder for the virus to spread.
Horse doc stated:

“Maybe they will die like Christ. You are pretty ok with that, as long as they do it far away, and off your radar screen. Christian death and sacrifice is all so messy and 1st century, isn’t it?

BTW - what have YOU sacrificed for your faith?’

Well ,what have you sacrificed? I have taken care of HIV and Hep C patients. What have you done? I did missionary work in Vietnam. I worked with Hansen Disease patients.
Yes, they should be far away. Death and sacrifice is fine, just let me do it at my own choosing, not some missionary who stayed in a hot zone and took my decision away from me.