But what would a “legitimate case” really mean?
There’s no higher Court than SCOTUS. There’s no official standard for recusal, it’s left to the Justices to do it on their own.
The only way to sanction a Justice is through the impeachment process. Good luck with that, it would have as much a chance of success as repealing the 2nd Amendment.
Being a chief justice means something like this:
I never lie, I always tell the truth. If you don’t believe that, you can just ask me.
The other justices should have at least forced the two to address the filing against them asking for their recusal.
“Theres no higher Court than SCOTUS”
God Almighty/The Lord Jesus Christ and He has already spoken on it....I am sure you will agree