[Ray76]

Lawyer has to use phone - therefor lawyer was not at office computer

Response was not ready until 8PM - why wasn’t lawyer at office preparing response?

It seems pretty clear the lawyer is lying.

[imardmd1]

What lawyer would be in his/her (actually, her) office at 8 pm? What secretary works in the office until 8 pm? But even if so, how was the lawyer contacting the site where the file of docs was reposing? by voice person to person? by SMS texting on the smartphone? by back-and-forth email messages? This whole narrative is very cloudy, without factual information, and sounds either improbable or impossible.