If the government compels a man to pay a certain amount for an insurance contract he neither wants or needs, it’s a tax. If the government compels a man to pay a certain amount he doesn’t want to pay to the state, it’s not a tax.
Isn’t the definition of a tax money sent to the Government for it’s constitutionaly autherized duties?
Not money forcefully sent directly to a 3rd party outside of the constitution?
Forcing people to donate to a spesfic Charity is a corrupt tax not a Charity. If it were we could all sell our services as a charity with required donation